Zeta Zeros
Display
Theme
Motion

Status tags

Every claim, by status tag

Each coloured or bracketed tag on this site says how much weight a sentence can bear. Click any tag on any page to come here; each entry below links back to the exact spot. Tags inside an existing link are listed here but not made clickable (a link cannot sit inside another link).

The tag set

  • Settled (151): Established mathematics: proved theorems or verified facts from the literature.
  • Open (84): An open problem: not known to be true or false.
  • Speculative (32): An unproved direction or hunch; may be wrong.
  • Known (213): Established mathematics, cited to a source.
  • Project (332): Our own derivation, computation or experiment in these notes. Not a claim of novelty.
  • Known + project (47): Known mathematics, with our own check, illustration or computation added.
  • Original proof (7): Proved here by an elementary argument; not found in the sources we checked.

How labels were normalised

The pages use several spellings and sub-labels. They map to the canonical set like this; the sub-label is kept on each entry.

  • Settled ← “coloured chip “Settled” (span.flag, data-status=settled)” ×151
  • Open ← “coloured chip “Open” (span.flag, data-status=open)” ×84
  • Speculative ← “[speculative]” ×17; “coloured chip “Speculative” (span.flag, data-status=speculative)” ×15
  • Known ← “[known]” ×195; “[known · primary]” ×8; “[open]” ×3; “[known consequence]” ×2; “[known; source access stated]” ×1; “[known/speculative]” ×1; “[known · checked example]” ×1; “[known · primary computational data]” ×1; “” ×1
  • Project ← “[project]” ×185; “[project, proved]” ×34; “[project, float numerics]” ×12; “[project · checked]” ×10; “[project · reproducible]” ×9; “[project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]” ×8; “[project · interval proof]” ×6; “[project, computer-assisted]” ×5; “[project, floating-point numerics, conditional on Artin holomorphy]” ×3; “[project · proved, refereed]” ×3; “[project, interval certificates]” ×2; “[project, proved — computer-assisted]” ×2; “[project, interval arithmetic, conditional]” ×2; “[project · proved]” ×2; “[project · proved, computer-assisted, double-computed]” ×2; “[project, computed]” ×2; “[project, checked findings]” ×1; “[project · exact deduction]” ×1; “[project · checked models]” ×1; “[project · computed]” ×1; “[project · exact arithmetic]” ×1; “[project · actual Artin values]” ×1; “[project · interval certified]” ×1; “[project · proved for these examples]” ×1; “[project · scope]” ×1; “[project · important control]” ×1; “[project · exact proof and checks]” ×1; “[project · floating point]” ×1; “[project · interpretation]” ×1; “[project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic + earlier slope check]” ×1; “[project, local root numbers + float numerics]” ×1; “[project, computer-assisted + float numerics]” ×1; “[project, interval arithmetic + float numerics]” ×1; “[project, proved; checked by script]” ×1; “[project, conditional on Artin holomorphy for ρ, ρ′, Sym³ρ]” ×1; “[project, floating-point numerics]” ×1; “[project, proof sketch]” ×1; “[project · actual Artin measurements]” ×1; “[project · numerical only]” ×1; “[project · limit]” ×1; “[project · independently counted]” ×1; “[project · assurance and scope]” ×1; “[project · our own names]” ×1; “[project, proved in these notes]” ×1; “[project · proved, double-computed]” ×1; “[project · proved, computer-assisted]” ×1; “[project · computed exactly]” ×1; “[project · proved, computer-assisted, independently re-computed]” ×1; “[project, double-computed]” ×1; “[project, proved from the local counts]” ×1; “[project, exact test]” ×1; “[project conjecture]” ×1; “[project, exact from the local polynomials]” ×1; “[project, proved / numerical coordinates]” ×1; “[project · proved and checked]” ×1; “[project · correction]” ×1; “[project · important limit]” ×1; “[project · proved for this arrangement]” ×1; “[project · exact constructed toy]” ×1; “[project · exact]” ×1; “[project, exact from established factors]” ×1
  • Known + project ← “[known / project]” ×14; “[known/project]” ×12; “[known / project checked]” ×3; “[known / project, proved]” ×3; “[known / project, illustration]” ×2; “[project, float numerics + proof from known local facts]” ×1; “[project, proved from known local facts]” ×1; “[known formula / project numerical checks]” ×1; “[known consequence / project checked]” ×1; “[known formula · project 60-digit check]” ×1; “[known / project · sources and reproduction]” ×1; “[known/project · important correction]” ×1; “[known/project · exact enumeration]” ×1; “[project · numerical check of known identities]” ×1; “[known/project · normalization matters]” ×1; “[known/project · sources and reproduction]” ×1; “[known / project illustration]” ×1; “[known / project adaptation]” ×1
  • Original proof ← “[original proof]” ×7

Settled (151)

Established mathematics: proved theorems or verified facts from the literature.

  1. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 2. Why anyone wanted it: cubics, not quadratics Settled
    Computed: the roots of x³ − 15x − 4 are 4 and −2 ± √3 (-3.7321, -0.2679); (2 + i)³ = 2 + 11i. Inside Cardano’s square root sits (q/2)² − (p/3)³ = 4 − 125 = -121. Settled history: Cardano 1545,…
  2. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 3. The picture: a second number line, at right angles Settled
    Settled A common misreading: i does not bend or curve the number line. The real line stays straight and the plane is flat. What i does is turn , as the next section shows. Caspar Wessel (1799),…
  3. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 3. The picture: a second number line, at right angles Settled
    The vertical axis starts on top of the real line and rotates by 90° into place: the same straight line, turned. Settled Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for reduced motion.
  4. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 4. Multiplying is turning and stretching Settled
    Computed: |2 + i| = |1 + 2i| = 2.2361 and |5i| = 5; the angles 26.5651° + 63.4349° = 90°. The spiral is the path z·|w| s e is·arg w for s from 0 to 1. Settled Motion plays on load and is off if…
  5. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 5. Euler’s formula: motion on a circle Settled
    Computed with Python cmath: e iπ evaluates to -1 + 1.2e-16i, the tiny imaginary part being rounding in floating point. Settled Euler 1748. Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for…
  6. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 6. A function moves the whole plane Settled
    Computed with Python cmath: 13 + 13 grid lines on [−1.5, 1.5]² (left, middle) and on [−1, 1] × [−π, π] (right), each sampled at 81 points and mapped exactly. Settled Motion plays on load and is…
  7. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 7. The bridge to ζ Settled
    Settled The imaginary axis is the vertical line where the real part is 0: numbers 0 + ti. The critical line is a different vertical line, half a unit to its right: numbers 1/2 + ti.
  8. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 7. The bridge to ζ Settled
    Settled The critical strip is everything with real part strictly between 0 and 1. All the nontrivial zeros lie in it. The trivial zeros are −2, −4, −6, … on the real axis; they come from the…
  9. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 7. The bridge to ζ Settled
    Settled Feed every point 1/2 + it of the critical line into ζ and plot the outputs: you get a curve that loops around the origin. Each time it passes exactly through 0 is a zero on the line. The…
  10. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 7. The bridge to ζ Settled
    Computed with mpmath 1.4.1: zetazero(k) for k = 1 to 10, and ζ(1/2 + it) at 1001 points with step 0.05 for 0 ≤ t ≤ 50 (values beyond ±4.2 clipped to the frame). ζ(1/2) ≈ −1.4604. The heights of…
  11. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 8. A fun true fact: knight moves are Gaussian integers Settled
    Settled 5 = (1 + 2i)(1 − 2i). An odd prime splits into two Gaussian factors exactly when it leaves remainder 1 on division by 4 (Fermat’s two-squares theorem). Primes like 3 and 7, with remainder…
  12. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 8. A fun true fact: knight moves are Gaussian integers Settled
    Settled The number of Gaussian integers of norm n is 4 × (divisors of n that are 1 mod 4 − divisors that are 3 mod 4). The zeta function that counts them, the Dedekind zeta function of the…
  13. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 8. A fun true fact: knight moves are Gaussian integers Settled
    Computed: a direct count of a + bi with a² + b² = n for n = 1 to 25 agrees with the divisor formula in every case; n = 5 gives 8, n = 25 gives 12, and n = 3, 7, 11, 19, 21, 23 give 0. Settled…
  14. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › Where to go next Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  15. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  16. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 12. Sources Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  17. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Sources Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  18. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The notebook behind the tangent Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  19. Zeta zeros Settled
    Settled standard mathematics, or computed here on a stated range
  20. Zeta zeros Settled A known function on a short interval
    |ζ(1/2 + it)| for 0 ≤ t ≤ 50. The curve touches zero at the first ten nontrivial zeros, γ 1 ≈ 14.13 to γ 10 ≈ 49.77. Data: computed with mpmath on a grid of spacing 0.05, 3 October 2026 PT.…
  21. Zeta zeros › What the zeros are Settled
    Settled Trivial zeros at the negative even integers come from the gamma factor in the functional equation ξ(s) = ξ(1 − s).
  22. Zeta zeros › What the zeros are Settled
    Settled Nontrivial zeros lie in the critical strip, come in conjugate pairs, are symmetric under s ↦ 1 − s, and are infinite in number: about (T/2π) log(T/2πe) of them up to height T.
  23. Zeta zeros › What the zeros are Settled
    Settled Every zero up to height 3·10 12 is on the critical line (Platt–Trudgian 2021), and infinitely many are on it (Hardy 1914).
  24. Zeta zeros › The Hypothesis 20 figures Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  25. Method and status Settled
    Every figure is computed here or taken from a cited table. Sentences carry a flag: Settled , Open , or Speculative .
  26. Method and status › Clay Millennium Prize Settled Institute rules
    Settled Institute rules The Clay Mathematics Institute does not accept direct submissions. A proposed solution is considered only after publication in a qualifying outlet, at least two years from…
  27. Method and status › Figures, and what they are not Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Full note above
  28. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  29. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Start here Settled
    Settled Checking has reached every zero up to height 3·10 12 , and each lies on the line (Platt and Trudgian, 2021). That is a finite check. Proofs about all the zeros say less: no zeros on the…
  30. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Start here Settled
    Settled The same open question can be restated without naming the zeros of ζ: as a claim about zeros of ζ′, about divisor sums (Robin), about harmonic numbers (Lagarias), about a power series…
  31. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › At a glance: proven, open, metaphor Settled Proven
    Settled Proven
  32. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › At a glance: proven, open, metaphor Settled Computed here
    Settled Computed here
  33. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › How far the checking has reached Settled
    Record counts of nontrivial zeros shown to lie on the critical line, 1859 to 2021, from the table of numerical calculations in the English Wikipedia article “Riemann hypothesis” (read 19 October…
  34. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › How far the checking has reached Settled
    Settled The jump in 1953 is Turing: the first time a digital computer was used on the zeros, and the first use of his counting trick, which is still the standard way to rule out zeros hiding off…
  35. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › How far the checking has reached Settled
    Settled The vertical scale is logarithmic, so the steady climb since the 1950s means the count has grown about tenfold every seven years since Turing (1,104 zeros in 1953 to about 1.2·10¹³ in…
  36. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › What is proved, and what is only checked Settled
    Settled The red slivers are thin, and they get thinner as you go up, so the proved zero-free region shrinks toward nothing. Proving the Hypothesis would mean widening them until they meet in the…
  37. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › What is proved, and what is only checked Settled
    Settled Hardy (1914) showed infinitely many zeros lie on the line, but infinitely many can still be 0% of them. Selberg (1942) was the first to prove a positive share. Levinson (1974), Conrey…
  38. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked of the derivative Settled
    Computed with mpmath 1.4.1 at 20 digits, 21 October 2026 PT. The 19 zeros of ζ′ with 1 ≤ t ≤ 100 were located with Newton’s method ( findroot on zeta(s, derivative=1) ) from a grid of starting…
  39. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked of the derivative Settled
    Settled Speiser’s argument is geometric: he studied the curves on which ζ(s) takes real values and how they pass through the zeros. Levinson and Montgomery (1974) gave an analytic proof and a…
  40. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked of the derivative Settled
    Settled Levinson’s proof the same year that more than one third of the zeros lie on the line, the bar labelled Levinson 1974 in the figure above, also works with ζ and ζ′ together.
  41. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked of the derivative Settled
    Settled Levinson and Montgomery also showed that, on average, zeros of ζ′ crowd toward σ = 1/2 as t grows, though slowly; here the closest is 0.78, at height 95.3. Several sit to the right of σ =…
  42. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked of whole numbers Settled
    Settled Gronwall (1913): the largest values of σ(n) / (n ln ln n) approach e γ as n grows (the limit superior is e γ ).
  43. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked of whole numbers Settled
    Settled Robin (1984): the Riemann Hypothesis holds if and only if σ(n) < e γ n ln ln n for all n > 5040. Robin also proved, with no hypothesis, a slightly weaker bound that holds for every n ≥ 3.…
  44. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked of whole numbers Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here No n from 5041 to 10 7 breaks the inequality. Far larger checks exist: Briggs (2006) tested the most dangerous candidates (the colossally abundant numbers) much further out.…
  45. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked of whole numbers Settled
    Settled Robin also showed that if the Hypothesis fails, then some colossally abundant number breaks the inequality. These are numbers built like 5040 = 2 4 · 3 2 · 5 · 7, packed with small primes,…
  46. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with harmonic numbers Settled
    Settled Lagarias (2002): the inequality σ(n) ≤ H n + exp(H n ) ln(H n ) for every integer n ≥ 1, with equality only at n = 1, is equivalent to the Riemann Hypothesis.
  47. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with harmonic numbers Settled
    Settled Relation to Robin (1984): Robin’s inequality σ(n) < e γ n ln ln n for all n > 5040 is also equivalent to RH. Lagarias’s form is a close elementary cousin that starts at n = 1 and writes…
  48. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with harmonic numbers Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here Every n from 1 to 10 7 satisfies the inequality; equality holds only at n = 1; the closest approach afterward is n = 12 at 0.9886. That is a finite check of an equivalent…
  49. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with ζ(2), ζ(4), ζ(6), … Settled
    Settled Riesz (1916): the Riemann Hypothesis is equivalent to F(x) = O(x 1/4+ε ) for every ε > 0, with F(x) = Σ (−1) k+1 x k / ((k−1)! ζ(2k)). Unconditionally F(x) = O(x 1/2+ε ).
  50. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with ζ(2), ζ(4), ζ(6), … Settled
    Settled Hardy and Littlewood (Acta Mathematica 41): RH is equivalent to Σ (−x) k / (k! ζ(2k+1)) = O(x −1/4+ε ) for every ε > 0.
  51. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with ζ(2), ζ(4), ζ(6), … Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here From x = 1 to 10 6 , |F(x)| / x 1/4 never exceeds 0.519; beyond x ≈ 20,000 the oscillation has the constant height 7.775e-05 · x 1/4 set by the first zero. The split into a…
  52. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with ζ(3), ζ(5), ζ(7), … Settled
    Settled Hardy and Littlewood (Acta Mathematica 41, 1918; see Titchmarsh §14.32): RH is equivalent to Σ (−x) k / (k! ζ(2k+1)) = O(x −1/4+ε ) for every ε > 0.
  53. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with ζ(3), ζ(5), ζ(7), … Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here From x = 3000 to 10 6 the wave left after removing the trivial-zero part has constant height 2.926e-05 · x −1/4 . The split into parts is our own residue bookkeeping, checked…
  54. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A coin-flip walk over the whole numbers Settled
    Settled Littlewood (1912): RH holds if and only if M(x) = O(x 1/2 + ε ) for every ε > 0.
  55. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A coin-flip walk over the whole numbers Settled
    Settled Odlyzko and te Riele (1985) disproved the Mertens conjecture |M(x)| < √x. Pintz (1987) showed a counterexample exists below exp(3.21 × 10 64 ); Kotnik and te Riele (2006) lowered that to…
  56. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A coin-flip walk over the whole numbers Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here Up to 10 9 the band stays well inside ±1, as the published computations to 10 16 also find. That supports nothing beyond this range, and the Hypothesis remains open .
  57. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A ladder of numbers that must all stay positive Settled
    Settled Li (1997): RH holds if and only if λ n ≥ 0 for every n ≥ 1. Bombieri and Lagarias (1999) showed the same positivity test works for any suitable collection of points, not just zeta zeros,…
  58. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A ladder of numbers that must all stay positive Settled
    Settled If RH holds, λ n = (n/2)(log n − 1 − log 2π + γ) + O(√n log n) (Lagarias 2007); Voros (2006) showed that this kind of tame growth holds if and only if RH does, and Arias de Reyna (2011)…
  59. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A ladder of numbers that must all stay positive Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here λ 1 to λ 500 are all positive. Much longer runs agree: Keiper (1992) went to n = 7000, Maślanka (2004) published about 3300 values, and Fredrik Johansson (2015) computed…
  60. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A ladder of numbers that must all stay positive Settled Reformulation
    Settled Reformulation Li’s criterion restates RH; it does not make it easier. A finite list of positive λ n , however long, can never prove RH.
  61. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Polynomials that copy ξ, and must all have real roots Settled
    Settled Pólya (1927), building on Jensen (1913): RH holds if and only if J d,n is hyperbolic for all d ≥ 1 and n ≥ 0. Because hyperbolicity survives taking derivatives, the shift-zero polynomials…
  62. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Polynomials that copy ξ, and must all have real roots Settled
    Settled Degrees 2 and 3 are hyperbolic for every shift (Csordas, Norfolk and Varga 1986; Dimitrov and Lucas 2011). Griffin, Ono, Rolen and Zagier (2019) proved every degree d is hyperbolic for all…
  63. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Polynomials that copy ξ, and must all have real roots Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here All roots computed above are real. That repeats known results; it adds no new evidence.
  64. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Polynomials that copy ξ, and must all have real roots Settled Reformulation
    Settled Reformulation “For all large n” leaves finitely many exceptions open in each degree, and infinitely many degrees remain. The Hypothesis itself is still open .
  65. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Heat flow on ξ, and a constant that pins RH to a single number Settled
    Settled de Bruijn (1950): all zeros of H t are real for t ≥ ½. Newman (1976): there is a constant Λ ≤ ½ with all zeros real exactly when t ≥ Λ; RH is equivalent to Λ ≤ 0. Ki, Kim and Lee (2009)…
  66. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Heat flow on ξ, and a constant that pins RH to a single number Settled
    Settled Λ ≥ 0 (Rodgers and Tao, 2020), proving a conjecture Newman made in 1976 as “a quantitative version of the dictum that the Riemann hypothesis, if true, is only barely so.” Together with RH…
  67. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Heat flow on ξ, and a constant that pins RH to a single number Settled
    Settled Λ ≤ 0.22 (the Polymath 15 project, 2019), improved to Λ ≤ 0.2 (Platt and Trudgian, 2021) using their check that RH holds up to height 3·10 12 . So today 0 ≤ Λ ≤ 0.2, the gold band in the…
  68. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Heat flow on ξ, and a constant that pins RH to a single number Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here The twenty lowest zeros of H t stay real for −0.5 ≤ t ≤ 0.5 and grow more evenly spaced as t rises. That illustrates the heat-flow picture; it adds no evidence about Λ.
  69. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question for other L-functions Settled
    Settled Large computer checks exist here too. Rumely (1993) and later Platt (2016) verified that the zeros of all Dirichlet L-functions with modulus up to large bounds lie on the line up to…
  70. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question for other L-functions Settled
    Settled Many theorems are proved conditionally , assuming the Generalized Hypothesis: for example, sharp bounds on the least prime in a progression and fast deterministic primality tests. If the…
  71. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Chebyshev’s bias: a prime race steered by the mod 4 zeros Settled
    Settled The lead changes sign infinitely often: the 4n + 1 team takes the lead for arbitrarily large x (Littlewood, 1914). This is proved without assuming any Riemann Hypothesis.
  72. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Chebyshev’s bias: a prime race steered by the mod 4 zeros Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here Up to 10 10 , the 4n + 3 team is strictly ahead at 99.28% of whole numbers x, tied at 0.0015%, and behind at 0.72%. Most of that 0.72% comes from the single long fifth stretch.
  73. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Where the same question is already a theorem: curves over finite fields Settled
    Settled Hasse (1933, full proof 1936): for every elliptic curve over a finite field F q , |#E(F q ) − (q + 1)| ≤ 2√q. Equivalently, the zeros of its zeta function lie on |T| = q −1/2 .
  74. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Where the same question is already a theorem: curves over finite fields Settled
    Settled Weil (1948): the same Riemann Hypothesis holds for the zeta function of every nonsingular projective curve over a finite field (any genus). The later Weil conjectures for…
  75. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Where the same question is already a theorem: curves over finite fields Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here 6,132 normalized Frobenius traces for five curves and every good prime up to 10,000 all satisfy |a p |/(2√p) ≤ 1; the closest to the bound is 0.9998. That is a check of the…
  76. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Why the prime product matters: a look-alike that breaks the rule Settled
    Settled The Davenport–Heilbronn function has infinitely many zeros with real part greater than 1, where no L-function can vanish (Davenport and Heilbronn, 1936), and also zeros inside the strip…
  77. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Why the prime product matters: a look-alike that breaks the rule Settled
    Settled Even so, it has infinitely many zeros exactly on the line (Voronin, 1980; Karatsuba later sharpened the count), and 122 of the 130 zeros found here are on it. A function can look “mostly…
  78. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A schematic of the plane Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  79. Sources › Data and computation Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  80. Statistics of the zeros Settled
    Settled standard mathematics, or computed here on a stated range
  81. Statistics of the zeros › Numerical verification Settled Proved up to a height
    Settled Proved up to a height Platt and Trudgian, Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society 53 (2021), using interval arithmetic: every nontrivial zero with imaginary part at most…
  82. Statistics of the zeros › Zeros forced onto the line, but not all of them Settled Proved partial results
    Settled Proved partial results The published chain, each step unconditional:
  83. Statistics of the zeros › Zero-free regions Settled Proved, and short of the line
    Settled Proved, and short of the line There is a classical region, going back to de la Vallée Poussin, in which ζ(σ + it) ≠ 0 for
  84. Statistics of the zeros › Zero-free regions Settled published theorem, evaluated here
    Settled published theorem, evaluated here Near the first zero, t ≈ 14.1347, the classical region only reaches down to σ ≈ 0.932. The zero itself is at σ = ½, far outside it. At t = 1000 the band…
  85. Statistics of the zeros › Zero-free regions Settled published theorem, evaluated here
    Settled published theorem, evaluated here Just above the checked range, at t = 3·10 12 , the band is 0.00626 wide. Counting its mirror image near σ = 0 (the functional equation reflects zeros…
  86. Statistics of the zeros › Zero-free regions Settled published theorems, crossing computed here
    Settled published theorems, crossing computed here The band keeps shrinking, like 1/log t. The Vinogradov–Korobov shape shrinks more slowly, but its constant is ten times bigger, so it only wins…
  87. Statistics of the zeros › GUE, Montgomery, Odlyzko Settled Level repulsion is plainly visible
    Data: the first 100 000 zeros from Odlyzko’s tables (file zeros1 , heights 14.13 to 74 920.83, stated accuracy 3·10 −9 ), downloaded 6 October 2026 PT. Its first 1000 ordinates agree with an…
  88. Statistics of the zeros › GUE, Montgomery, Odlyzko Settled Finite windows, standard statistics
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT from Odlyzko’s tables, unfolded with the smooth zero count (θ(t)/π for the high windows, mpmath at 40 digits). Each point averages 200 000 random window positions. GUE…
  89. Statistics of the zeros › Closest calls: Lehmer pairs Settled
    Hardy Z(t) around three pairs of neighbouring zeros. Ordinates from Odlyzko’s table of the first 100 000 zeros; Z(t) computed with mpmath 1.4.1 siegelz at 30 digits, 7 October 2026 PT. A typical…
  90. Statistics of the zeros › Closest calls: Lehmer pairs Settled
    Settled If one of these small swings had failed to cross zero, Z(t) would show two fewer sign changes than the zero count N(T) requires. That would put two zeros off the critical line, a…
  91. Statistics of the zeros › Closest calls: Lehmer pairs Settled Computed here
    Settled Computed here Among the 99 999 gaps in the first 100 000 zeros, 79 are smaller than 0.1 mean spacings. Independent random points (Poisson) would give about 9 500 such gaps; the GUE Wigner…
  92. Statistics of the zeros › Closest calls: Lehmer pairs Settled
    Settled Lehmer pairs are tied to the de Bruijn–Newman constant Λ, which measures how close ζ is to having a zero off the line under a heat-flow deformation. The Riemann Hypothesis is equivalent to…
  93. Statistics of the zeros › Closest calls: Lehmer pairs Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  94. Zeros and primes Settled
    Settled standard mathematics, or computed here on a stated range
  95. Zeros and primes › Primes and the Euler product Settled
    Settled Every integer greater than 1 factors into primes in exactly one way, up to order. Euler turned that unique factorization into an identity of functions. For real part greater than 1, the…
  96. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled
    |ζ(σ + it)| for 0 ≤ t ≤ 40 on σ = 2 (top) and σ = 1.2 (bottom), dashed, against the partial product over primes p ≤ P, teal. Steps: the first 15 primes one by one, then all primes up to 100, 1000…
  97. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled
    Settled Each factor expands as 1 + p −s + p −2s + …. Multiplying the factors for all primes produces every term n −s exactly once, because every integer factors into primes in exactly one way.…
  98. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled Computed here
    Settled Computed here On σ = 2, the prime 2 alone already gets within 19% of |ζ| everywhere in the window. The first 15 primes (up to 47) get within 0.39%, and all 1229 primes below 10 000 get…
  99. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled Computed here
    Settled Computed here On σ = 1.2, six of the seven dips in |ζ| sit within 0.15 of the height of one of the first six zeros on the critical line (t = 14.13, 21.02, 25.01, 30.42, 32.94, 37.59; red…
  100. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled Caveat
    Settled Computed here On σ = 1.2, six of the seven dips in |ζ| sit within 0.15 of the height of one of the first six zeros on the critical line (t = 14.13, 21.02, 25.01, 30.42, 32.94, 37.59; red…
  101. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled
    Ξ(t) := ξ(1/2 + it) for −40 ≤ t ≤ 40, computed with mpmath 1.4.1 at 30 digits from the classical formula ξ(s) = ½ s(s−1) π^(−s/2) Γ(s/2) ζ(s), 13 October 2026 PT. Vertical scale is a signed asinh…
  102. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled
    Settled Why Ξ is real: the factors in ξ cancel the complex phase of ζ on the critical line, just as Hardy’s Z does. Plotting Ξ therefore shows sign changes, not only a modulus touching zero.
  103. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled
    Settled Why Ξ is even: ξ(s) = ξ(1 − s) together with conjugation symmetry forces Ξ(−t) = Ξ(t). The mirror image across t = 0 in the figure is that identity, not a coincidence of the window.
  104. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Settled
    Settled The zeros of Ξ on the real t-axis are exactly the imaginary parts of the nontrivial zeros of ζ. The Riemann Hypothesis is the claim that every nontrivial zero has real part 1/2 —…
  105. Zeros and primes › A gas whose partition function is ζ Settled
    Settled The primon gas identity Z(β) = ζ(β) for β > 1 is exact; it is Euler’s product written as a gas of free particles (Julia 1990; Spector 1990, who also read the Möbius function as the…
  106. Zeros and primes › A gas whose partition function is ζ Settled
    Settled Bost–Connes (1995), main theorem: for 0 < β ≤ 1 there is a unique equilibrium (KMS) state; for β > 1 the extreme equilibrium states are permuted by the symmetry group, which is the Galois…
  107. Zeros and primes › The explicit formula Settled Theorem about whatever zeros exist
    Settled Theorem about whatever zeros exist It does not force those zeros onto the line.
  108. Zeros and primes › The explicit formula Settled Stable arithmetic, not a monotone error
    Computed for x ≤ 100. Gold dashes: five pairs. Teal: twenty pairs. They lie on top of each other at this scale; the next figure is the difference. Signed residual ψ minus truncation, five pairs…
  109. Zeros and primes › The explicit formula Settled The formula is a theorem; this is arithmetic with known zeros
    Drag the slider or press Play. The teal curve is x − Σ x ρ /ρ − log 2π − ½ log(1 − x −2 ) summed over the first N conjugate pairs; the red staircase is the exact ψ(x); the lower panel is the…
  110. Zeros and primes › The explicit formula Settled Why a longer sum need not help at every x
    Settled Why a longer sum need not help at every x Each omitted zero contributes a term of size about x β /|ρ| that oscillates in log x. Adding the next conjugate pair is adding another wave, not…
  111. Zeros and primes › How far the primes stray: π(x), li(x) and R(x) Settled A sieve and a quadrature
    Computed, x ≤ 1000. π(1000) = 168. li(1000) ≈ 177.610. Settled A sieve and a quadrature . Open Still not a test of the square-root error , and not the von Koch bound.
  112. Zeros and primes › How far the primes stray: π(x), li(x) and R(x) Settled Every sample on this grid is positive
    Computed signed error li(x) − π(x), x ≤ 10 000. Red dots are the checkpoints above. The curve is jagged because π jumps at primes while li is smooth. Settled Every sample on this grid is positive…
  113. Zeros and primes › Riemann’s R(x): a better smooth guess Settled Settled definition, computed comparison
    Settled Settled definition, computed comparison Riemann himself proposed a sharper smooth approximation than li(x). It corrects for prime powers, which li over-counts, using the Möbius function μ:
  114. Zeros and primes › Riemann’s R(x): a better smooth guess Settled A better main term on a short range
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT: sieve for π(x), mpmath.li and mpmath.riemannr (mpmath 1.4.1, 25 digits), sampled every 5 from 2 to 10 000 (2004 samples). R − π at the red dots: +0.662 at 100, +0.359…
  115. Zeros and primes › Riemann’s R(x): a better smooth guess Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  116. Zeros on the critical line Settled
    Settled standard mathematics, or computed here on a stated range
  117. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled Settled landscape
    Settled Settled landscape Open Open claim Separate the two.
  118. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled
    ζ(x) along the real axis, −20.5 ≤ x ≤ 6, computed with mpmath 1.4.1 at 30 digits, 9 October 2026 PT. The vertical scale is a signed asinh, so swings of 0.004 and of 34 both stay visible. The curve…
  119. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled
    Settled Why these points: the functional equation ties ζ(s) to ζ(1 − s) through a factor that includes sin(πs/2). That sine vanishes at every even integer. At s = 0 the pole of ζ(1 − s) cancels…
  120. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled
    Settled At the negative odd integers ζ takes rational values tied to Bernoulli numbers: ζ(−n) = (−1) n B n+1 /(n+1). That is where ζ(−1) = −1/12 comes from. It is a value of the continued…
  121. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled
    Settled The trivial zeros are fully understood, so all the open questions, including the Riemann Hypothesis, concern only the nontrivial zeros in the critical strip drawn below.
  122. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled the functional equation
    Settled the functional equation Why the two sides are tied: ζ(s) = χ(s) ζ(1 − s), and χ has no zeros inside the strip. So the size of ζ at σ + it is the size at the mirror point 1 − σ + it, times…
  123. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled consequence
    Settled consequence If ζ were 0 at σ 0 + it with σ 0 ≠ ½, the factor would force a second zero at 1 − σ 0 + it. On the line itself |χ| = 1 exactly, so the gold curve crosses 0 at σ = ½: the line…
  124. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled These twenty zeros lie on the critical line
    All twenty were checked: real part 1/2, and |ζ| at each point under 10 −18 . The six-decimal values for n = 1…8 match the rounding already on this page. Settled These twenty zeros lie on the…
  125. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled These five are zeros on the line
    Computed, not a sketch of “some zeros.” Ordinates, to six decimals: 14.134725, 21.022040, 25.010858, 30.424876, 32.935062. The two-decimal labels are those values rounded. The printed gaps are the…
  126. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Settled A plot of a known function on a short interval
    Computed |ζ(1/2 + it)| on a grid of spacing 0.05, with the ten ordinates in this window inserted so the curve meets the axis there. |ζ(1/2)| ≈ 1.460. On this sample the largest value is about…
  127. Zeros on the critical line › Seeing the zeros as places where all the colours meet Settled
    Domain colouring of ζ(s) on 0 ≤ t ≤ 36, −1.5 ≤ σ ≤ 2.5, computed with mpmath 1.4.1 on a 720 × 200 grid, 16 October 2026 PT. Hue is the angle of ζ(s); brightness steps once per doubling of |ζ(s)|.…
  128. Zeros on the critical line › Seeing the zeros as places where all the colours meet Settled
    Settled A zero and a pole look alike at a glance, but the colours go round in opposite orders. That is the argument principle: the number of times the angle turns around a closed loop equals zeros…
  129. Zeros on the critical line › Seeing the zeros as places where all the colours meet Settled
    Settled To the right of σ = 1 the colours barely change, because ζ stays close to 1 there and has no zeros. Toward the left the bands bunch up as |ζ| grows; the trivial zeros at −2, −4, … are…
  130. Zeros on the critical line › Seeing the zeros as places where all the colours meet Settled
    Settled Nothing in the picture forces the meeting points onto the dashed line. In this window they happen to be there, and Platt and Trudgian (2021) checked every zero up to height 3·10¹², but a…
  131. Zeros on the critical line › The series does not converge on the line, yet ζ is still zero there Settled
    Partial sums at ρ 1 = 1/2 + 14.134725…i, N = 1…400, computed with mpmath 1.4.1 at 30 digits, 15 October 2026 PT (|ζ(ρ 1 )| evaluates to 6·10 −31 at that precision). Panel A: the plain sums S N…
  132. Zeros on the critical line › The series does not converge on the line, yet ζ is still zero there Settled
    Settled Panel A in words: S N ≈ ζ(s) + N 1−s /(1 − s). The second piece has length √N / |1 − s| and turns as N grows, so the sums circle the true value ζ(s) on a widening spiral. At a zero the…
  133. Zeros on the critical line › The series does not converge on the line, yet ζ is still zero there Settled
    Settled Panel B in words: the alternating series η(s) = 1 − 2 −s + 3 −s − … does converge for Re(s) > 0, and η(s) = (1 − 2 1−s ) ζ(s). The factor in front is not zero at ρ 1 , so η vanishes…
  134. Zeros on the critical line › The series does not converge on the line, yet ζ is still zero there Settled
    Settled Either route defines the same analytically continued ζ. The zeros on this page are zeros of that function, which is why they can be computed and checked to many digits.
  135. Zeros on the critical line › Chop the series off: the zeros leave the line Settled
    Settled Turán (1948) showed that if ζ N had no zeros with σ > 1 for all large N, the Riemann Hypothesis would follow. Montgomery (1983) showed that this fails: for large N there are zeros with σ >…
  136. Zeros on the critical line › Chop the series off: the zeros leave the line Settled
    Settled The count of zeros of ζ N up to height T is (T/2π)·log N + O(N) (Gonek and Ledoan, 2010).
  137. Zeros on the critical line › Chop the series off: the zeros leave the line Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here The pairing of filled dots with zeta zeros and the drift of the extra band are what this finite computation shows for three values of N up to height 60. The sentence about…
  138. Zeros on the critical line › How big is ζ on the line, on average? Settled
    Computed with mpmath 1.4.1, 22 October 2026 PT: |ζ(1/2 + it)|² on a grid of step 0.01 from t = 0 to 500 (50 001 values), integrated by Simpson’s rule. At T = 500 the integral is 2276.42, against…
  139. Zeros on the critical line › How big is ζ on the line, on average? Settled
    Settled Atkinson (1949) wrote E(T) exactly as a sum of oscillating terms, a cousin of the explicit formula on the zeros and primes page. That is why the bottom curve looks like a wave rather than…
  140. Zeros on the critical line › How big is ζ on the line, on average? Settled
    Settled The fourth power is also known: Ingham (1926) showed its average grows like (log T) 4 /(2π²). Open For the sixth and higher powers only conjectures exist; the leading constants predicted…
  141. Zeros on the critical line › How big is ζ at a random point? Selberg’s bell curve Settled
    Settled Selberg’s central limit theorem, for both log|ζ| and the angle of ζ (Selberg 1946; full proofs in Tsang’s 1984 thesis; a short modern proof by Radziwiłł and Soundararajan, 2017).
  142. Zeros on the critical line › How big is ζ at a random point? Selberg’s bell curve Settled Observed here
    Settled Observed here The data have the bell’s centre and rough shape, the leftward lean eases from -1.08 to -0.77 as the height grows, but the spread stays near 1.21–1.26. That is not a…
  143. Zeros on the critical line › Hardy’s Z(t): why sign changes certify zeros on the line Settled
    Settled |ζ| touches zero at a zero, but a modulus cannot change sign, so a plot of |ζ| alone cannot tell a true zero from a near miss. The functional equation fixes that. Define the Riemann–Siegel…
  144. Zeros on the critical line › Hardy’s Z(t): why sign changes certify zeros on the line Settled Thirteen zeros on the line
    Computed with mpmath.siegelz (mpmath 1.4.1, 25 digits) on a grid of spacing 0.05 for 0 ≤ t ≤ 60. Thirteen sign changes; refining each with a root finder reproduced mpmath.zetazero for n = 1…13,…
  145. Zeros on the critical line › Counting zeros: why sign changes are not enough by themselves Settled Settled method
    Settled Settled method Sign changes of Z find zeros on the line. They cannot see a zero that has left it. So verification compares two counts up to a height T: the number of sign changes of Z on…
  146. Zeros on the critical line › Counting zeros: why sign changes are not enough by themselves Settled A count on a finite range
    N(T) counted from Odlyzko’s published table of the first 100 000 zeros ( Odlyzko, zeta tables , stated accuracy 3·10 −9 ), and checked independently with mpmath.nzeros : N(100) = 29 and N(200) =…
  147. Zeros on the critical line › S(T) over a longer range Settled Settled theory, computed range
    Settled Settled theory, computed range The remainder S(T) = N(T) − θ(T)/π − 1 is exactly (1/π) arg ζ(1/2 + iT). It jumps up by 1 at each zero and slides down between zeros. Two classical facts…
  148. Zeros on the critical line › S(T) over a longer range Settled Finite ranges, standard theory
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT. Top: S(T) on a grid of step 0.005 from T = 14 to the 100 000th zero (T ≈ 74 920.83), with N(T) counted from Odlyzko’s table and θ(T) from its asymptotic series (checked…
  149. Zeros on the critical line › Gram’s law at three heights Settled Computed counts, proved theorems about failure
    Settled Computed counts, proved theorems about failure The gold Gram points on the Z(t) figure chop the line into Gram intervals, one zero’s worth of room each on average, because θ(t) advances by…
  150. Zeros on the critical line › Gram’s law at three heights Settled Counts on finite ranges
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT from Odlyzko’s tables. Low zeros: Gram points g 0 ≈ 17.846 onward from θ(g n ) = nπ (Newton’s method on the asymptotic series for θ, checked against mpmath.grampoint : g…
  151. Zeros on the critical line › Gram’s law at three heights Settled
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status

Open (84)

An open problem: not known to be true or false.

  1. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 7. The bridge to ζ Open
    Open The Riemann Hypothesis says every nontrivial zero has real part exactly 1/2. It is not proved. Every zero checked so far, up to height 3·10 12 , is on the line, but checking is not proof.
  2. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 7. The bridge to ζ Open
    Computed with mpmath 1.4.1: zetazero(k) for k = 1 to 10, and ζ(1/2 + it) at 1001 points with step 0.05 for 0 ≤ t ≤ 50 (values beyond ±4.2 clipped to the frame). ζ(1/2) ≈ −1.4604. The heights of…
  3. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › 8. A fun true fact: knight moves are Gaussian integers Open
    Open Whether all nontrivial zeros of L(s, χ 4 ) lie on the critical line is part of the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis. Results that depend on it are conditional.
  4. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › Where to go next Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  5. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  6. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 12. Sources Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  7. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Sources Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  8. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The notebook behind the tangent Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  9. Zeta zeros Open
    Open a conjecture or an unfinished item
  10. Zeta zeros Open Not a proof about the rest
    |ζ(1/2 + it)| for 0 ≤ t ≤ 50. The curve touches zero at the first ten nontrivial zeros, γ 1 ≈ 14.13 to γ 10 ≈ 49.77. Data: computed with mpmath on a grid of spacing 0.05, 3 October 2026 PT.…
  11. Zeta zeros › What the zeros are Open
    Open The Riemann Hypothesis , posed by Riemann in 1859, says all of them are. It is one conjecture about the zeros, not the name of this site.
  12. Zeta zeros › The Hypothesis 20 figures Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  13. Method and status Open
    Every figure is computed here or taken from a cited table. Sentences carry a flag: Settled , Open , or Speculative .
  14. Method and status › Figures, and what they are not Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Full note above
  15. Open questions › Classical open problems Open
    Open The Riemann Hypothesis : every nontrivial zero of ζ(s) has real part ½.
  16. Open questions › Classical open problems Open
    Open Simplicity: every nontrivial zero of ζ(s) is simple. Verified for every zero computed; not proved.
  17. Open questions › Classical open problems Open
    Open Montgomery’s pair-correlation conjecture and the full GUE statistics of the zeros, beyond the restricted test functions of Rudnick and Sarnak (1996). See statistics of the zeros .
  18. Open questions › Classical open problems Open
    Open The Lindelöf hypothesis: |ζ(½+it)| grows more slowly than any positive power of t.
  19. Open questions › Computations still open on this site Open
    Open Three-point and higher correlations of the zeros, from published tables.
  20. Open questions › Computations still open on this site Open
    Open A histogram of S(t) against Selberg’s Gaussian limit.
  21. Open questions › Computations still open on this site Open
    Open Larger high-altitude datasets than the public 10 000-zero windows used for the spacing figures.
  22. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open Is the full Solomon count for the split local Eichler family, Q r (v) = Σ d,e=0..r p min(d,e) v d+e , already in the literature? A short search found nothing; a paper we missed would have…
  23. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open A general local functional equation for Gorenstein or Bass quaternion orders. Bushnell–Reiner’s self-duality remark is a lead; our reading that their argument extends to the Atkin–Lehner dual…
  24. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open Integer-coordinate (Gravesian) octonions: a conceptual reason why the 2-local factor has period 4 rather than 8. The period itself is proved, computer-assisted.
  25. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open The intermediate octonion order R = Z⟨Z 8 , (1+e 1 +e 2 +e 4 )/2⟩: is it Gorenstein? And what are the local factors of the other intermediate orders?
  26. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open Quaternion Euler products built from actual Frobenius elements: any extension to complex s (where p −s and the Frobenius quaternion stop commuting), an octonionic version with real arithmetic…
  27. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open Simplicity of forced central zeros for Q 8 Artin L-functions beyond the 24 twists checked here; an audit of the twisted coefficients that is independent of the base coefficients.
  28. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open A direct, certified degree-eight Dedekind zeta evaluator for the Q 8 fields (not needed for the results above).
  29. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open A uniform field-and-family inequality excluding the Heilbronn character assignment at a hypothetical off-line ordinary zero.
  30. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open The topology at infinity of the norm-level tubes of ξ, beyond the bare zero-set end system already computed.
  31. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open A rate in the merged 2/3/5 gap law; this would need Baker-type bounds for linear forms in logarithms.
  32. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Open For the E 8 lattice zeta: further shell counts or zero families, only where they answer a specific question.
  33. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  34. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Start here Open
    In 1859 Riemann suggested that every nontrivial zero of ζ(s) has real part ½. Open The Hypothesis is unproved. It is a Millennium Prize problem; nothing on this site claims to settle it.
  35. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › At a glance: proven, open, metaphor Open
    Open
  36. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Honest status Open Open problem
    Open Open problem The Riemann Hypothesis is unproved. It is a Millennium Prize problem of the Clay Mathematics Institute. Bombieri’s official problem description is the short orientation written…
  37. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › How far the checking has reached Open
    Open Twelve trillion zeros on the line is strong evidence, but it is not a proof. Number theory has famous patterns that hold far beyond any computer’s reach and then fail, for example π(x) <…
  38. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › What is proved, and what is only checked Open Claimed
    Open Claimed The two 2026 results would be large jumps if they hold up: a share of two thirds instead of five twelfths, and a fixed zero-free strip to the right of 7/8. Neither is the Hypothesis,…
  39. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with harmonic numbers Open
    Open The Riemann Hypothesis itself. Nothing on this page claims it is settled; see Honest status .
  40. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with ζ(2), ζ(4), ζ(6), … Open
    Open The Riemann Hypothesis itself, the conjecture Riemann made in 1859. Nothing on this page claims it is settled; see Honest status .
  41. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question, asked with ζ(3), ζ(5), ζ(7), … Open
    Open The Riemann Hypothesis itself. See Honest status .
  42. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Heat flow on ξ, and a constant that pins RH to a single number Open
    Open Whether Λ = 0, which is exactly the Riemann Hypothesis. It is still open .
  43. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question for other L-functions Open
    Computed with mpmath 1.4.1 at 25 digits, 23 October 2026 PT, using dirichlet(s, χ) for the two characters and zeta(s) for ζ. Each function’s size on the line s = 1/2 + it was sampled every 0.02…
  44. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › The same question for other L-functions Open
    Open The zeros of the mod 4 function also explain Chebyshev’s observation that primes of the form 4k + 3 usually outnumber primes of the form 4k + 1. Rubinstein and Sarnak (1994) measured this…
  45. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Chebyshev’s bias: a prime race steered by the mod 4 zeros Open Conditional
    Open Conditional Counting each x with weight 1/x instead of 1 (the “logarithmic” share), Rubinstein and Sarnak (1994) showed that in the limit the 4n + 3 team leads 99.59% of the time (density…
  46. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Chebyshev’s bias: a prime race steered by the mod 4 zeros Open Conditional
    Open Conditional Assuming the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, Kaczorowski (1995) showed that with the ordinary weight 1 the share of x where 4n + 3 leads has no limit at all; it keeps drifting up…
  47. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Where the same question is already a theorem: curves over finite fields Open
    Open The Riemann Hypothesis for the ordinary zeta function ζ(s) of the integers. It is still open ; nothing on this page claims otherwise.
  48. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Why the prime product matters: a look-alike that breaks the rule Open Conditional
    Open Conditional Bombieri and Hejhal (1995) showed that, assuming the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis and a spacing hypothesis for the underlying L-functions, almost all (100% in proportion) of the…
  49. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › Why the prime product matters: a look-alike that breaks the rule Open
    Open The lesson most experts draw is that any proof of the Riemann Hypothesis must use the Euler product, the link to the primes, and not only the functional equation. This is a guide to strategy,…
  50. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A schematic of the plane Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  51. Sources › Data and computation Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  52. Statistics of the zeros Open
    Open a conjecture or an unfinished item
  53. Statistics of the zeros › Zero-free regions Open the Riemann Hypothesis
    Open the Riemann Hypothesis RH says the zero-free region is the whole strip except the line: width ½ on each side, the red dashed level in panel B. No proved region reaches any fixed distance from…
  54. Statistics of the zeros › GUE, Montgomery, Odlyzko Open Conjectural statistics, with numerical support
    Open Conjectural statistics, with numerical support Montgomery, in 1973, conjectured that the pair correlation of the zeros matches the Gaussian Unitary Ensemble. Dyson recognized the match. For…
  55. Statistics of the zeros › GUE, Montgomery, Odlyzko Open GUE for ζ is conjectural
    Data: the first 100 000 zeros from Odlyzko’s tables (file zeros1 , heights 14.13 to 74 920.83, stated accuracy 3·10 −9 ), downloaded 6 October 2026 PT. Its first 1000 ordinates agree with an…
  56. Statistics of the zeros › GUE, Montgomery, Odlyzko Open Montgomery’s full conjecture is open
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT from Odlyzko’s tables ( index ). Teal: all 250 810 pairs with unfolded separation below 3 among the first 100 000 zeros, in bins of width 0.05. In the first bin, [0,…
  57. Statistics of the zeros › GUE, Montgomery, Odlyzko Open GUE for ζ is a conjecture
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT. The teal curve here is the exact GUE spacing density, computed from the Fredholm determinant of the sine kernel by Bornemann’s quadrature method ( Math. Comp. 79, 2010;…
  58. Statistics of the zeros › GUE, Montgomery, Odlyzko Open GUE and Berry’s formula are conjectural for ζ
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT from Odlyzko’s tables, unfolded with the smooth zero count (θ(t)/π for the high windows, mpmath at 40 digits). Each point averages 200 000 random window positions. GUE…
  59. Statistics of the zeros › GUE, Montgomery, Odlyzko Open
    Partial theorems point the same way and still fall short. Rudnick and Sarnak (1996) match the GUE correlations for test functions whose Fourier transforms are supported in a bounded range, not…
  60. Statistics of the zeros › Closest calls: Lehmer pairs Open
    Settled Lehmer pairs are tied to the de Bruijn–Newman constant Λ, which measures how close ζ is to having a zero off the line under a heat-flow deformation. The Riemann Hypothesis is equivalent to…
  61. Statistics of the zeros › Closest calls: Lehmer pairs Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  62. Zeros and primes Open
    Open a conjecture or an unfinished item
  63. Zeros and primes › Building the product one prime at a time Open
    Settled The zeros of Ξ on the real t-axis are exactly the imaginary parts of the nontrivial zeros of ζ. The Riemann Hypothesis is the claim that every nontrivial zero has real part 1/2 —…
  64. Zeros and primes › A gas whose partition function is ζ Open Not a route to RH, as far as is known
    Open Not a route to RH, as far as is known The transition sits at the pole, β = 1 on the real axis. No result connects this symmetry breaking to where the nontrivial zeros lie. Connes later built…
  65. Zeros and primes › The explicit formula Open Not a proof that every zero has real part 1/2
    Drag the slider or press Play. The teal curve is x − Σ x ρ /ρ − log 2π − ½ log(1 − x −2 ) summed over the first N conjugate pairs; the red staircase is the exact ψ(x); the lower panel is the…
  66. Zeros and primes › How far the primes stray: π(x), li(x) and R(x) Open Conditional
    Open Conditional These are consequences of RH, or equivalents of it. They are not theorems of this project, and they are not known unconditionally at this strength.
  67. Zeros and primes › How far the primes stray: π(x), li(x) and R(x) Open Still not a test of the square-root error
    Computed, x ≤ 1000. π(1000) = 168. li(1000) ≈ 177.610. Settled A sieve and a quadrature . Open Still not a test of the square-root error , and not the von Koch bound.
  68. Zeros and primes › How far the primes stray: π(x), li(x) and R(x) Open No sign change claimed
    Computed signed error li(x) − π(x), x ≤ 10 000. Red dots are the checkpoints above. The curve is jagged because π jumps at primes while li is smooth. Settled Every sample on this grid is positive…
  69. Zeros and primes › Riemann’s R(x): a better smooth guess Open Not a test of the Hypothesis
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT: sieve for π(x), mpmath.li and mpmath.riemannr (mpmath 1.4.1, 25 digits), sampled every 5 from 2 to 10 000 (2004 samples). R − π at the red dots: +0.662 at 100, +0.359…
  70. Zeros and primes › Riemann’s R(x): a better smooth guess Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  71. Zeros on the critical line Open
    Open a conjecture or an unfinished item
  72. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Open Open claim
    Settled Settled landscape Open Open claim Separate the two.
  73. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Open the Riemann Hypothesis
    Open the Riemann Hypothesis The picture explains why off-line zeros would come in pairs. It does not show they never happen: three cuts at low height are evidence about these cuts only. RH, that…
  74. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Open Being on the line for n = 1…20 does not prove the Riemann Hypothesis
    All twenty were checked: real part 1/2, and |ζ| at each point under 10 −18 . The six-decimal values for n = 1…8 match the rounding already on this page. Settled These twenty zeros lie on the…
  75. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Open The Hypothesis is the claim about all the others
    Computed, not a sketch of “some zeros.” Ordinates, to six decimals: 14.134725, 21.022040, 25.010858, 30.424876, 32.935062. The two-decimal labels are those values rounded. The printed gaps are the…
  76. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line Open Twenty on the line is not the Hypothesis
    The same computation, drawn for n = 1…20. Labels are γ rounded to two decimals, so 14.134725 is labeled 14.13 and 77.144840 is labeled 77.14. Positive ordinates only; the conjugates are not drawn.…
  77. Zeros on the critical line › Seeing the zeros as places where all the colours meet Open
    Domain colouring of ζ(s) on 0 ≤ t ≤ 36, −1.5 ≤ σ ≤ 2.5, computed with mpmath 1.4.1 on a 720 × 200 grid, 16 October 2026 PT. Hue is the angle of ζ(s); brightness steps once per doubling of |ζ(s)|.…
  78. Zeros on the critical line › Chop the series off: the zeros leave the line Open
    Open None of this says anything about whether the zeros of ζ itself are all on the line.
  79. Zeros on the critical line › How big is ζ on the line, on average? Open
    Open Whether E(T) grows no faster than T 1/4 + ε for every ε > 0 is a standing conjecture.
  80. Zeros on the critical line › How big is ζ on the line, on average? Open
    Settled The fourth power is also known: Ingham (1926) showed its average grows like (log T) 4 /(2π²). Open For the sixth and higher powers only conjectures exist; the leading constants predicted…
  81. Zeros on the critical line › How big is ζ at a random point? Selberg’s bell curve Open
    Open How large ζ can get at its very biggest along the line, and the exact shape of the rare extreme values, are still being worked out. Conjectures from random matrices (Keating and Snaith, 2000)…
  82. Zeros on the critical line › Hardy’s Z(t): why sign changes certify zeros on the line Open Not a statement about the rest
    Computed with mpmath.siegelz (mpmath 1.4.1, 25 digits) on a grid of spacing 0.05 for 0 ≤ t ≤ 60. Thirteen sign changes; refining each with a root finder reproduced mpmath.zetazero for n = 1…13,…
  83. Zeros on the critical line › Gram’s law at three heights Open Says nothing about zeros off the line
    Computed 6 October 2026 PT from Odlyzko’s tables. Low zeros: Gram points g 0 ≈ 17.846 onward from θ(g n ) = nπ (Newton’s method on the asymptotic series for θ, checked against mpmath.grampoint : g…
  84. Zeros on the critical line › Gram’s law at three heights Open
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status

Speculative (32)

An unproved direction or hunch; may be wrong.

  1. Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros › Where to go next Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  2. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [speculative]
    [speculative] Possibly a wall further left. Euler products with non-integer exponents often cannot be continued past some line at all (a “natural boundary”), as in results of Estermann, Dahlquist…
  3. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [speculative]
    [speculative] In all three 2I fields examined, the root numbers of ρ and Sym³ρ have opposite signs. Whether that is forced is not known.
  4. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [speculative]
    [speculative] Is it forced for every binary-icosahedral field? In every case checked (eleven representations, three of them independent) the local signs at the prime or primes where the group acts…
  5. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [speculative]
    [speculative] Selberg’s mollifier is itself built from a half power of ζ, and F’s main factor is L(ρ) 1/2 . We found no mathematical use for the resemblance. No bearing on the Riemann Hypothesis.…
  6. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Every order between Z 8 and E 8 [speculative]
    [speculative] We also tried the octonion version of a standard test for “well-behaved” (Gorenstein) orders: is the dual lattice a single multiple S·α? This is the quaternion criterion of Voight,…
  7. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The horned-sphere question was not finished [speculative]
    [speculative] A good next question is which features of those infinite ends survive beyond the bare zero count, and whether norm-level surfaces add structure that the zero set alone misses. A…
  8. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [speculative]
    [speculative] The Artin height-100 and negative-twist tasks mentioned in older sections are now completed for the stated finite examples. Open questions include an arithmetic explanation of G’s…
  9. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  10. How much of the critical line can we prove? [speculative]
    [known] How to read the labels. Every claim carries one tag. [known] is published mathematics, with the source named (full list in the sources ). [project] is something we computed or checked…
  11. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [speculative]
    No Z-function, no mirror identity [project] elementary . The representation above gives F no reflection law about ½: the factor [ζ(2s)/L(χ u , 2s)] 1/4 reflects about s = ¼ (2s ↔ 1 − 2s), and G is…
  12. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [speculative]
    10.3 Plain summary. Sign changes (Hardy, Selberg) and Levinson's identity need a real-valued function on the line coming from a functional equation. The classical L(ρ) has one; the aligned…
  13. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 12. Sources Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  14. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture [speculative]
    [known] How to read the labels. Every claim carries one tag. [known] is published mathematics, with the source named (full list in the sources and in the primer ). [project] is a figure or check…
  15. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Deninger’s proposed dictionary [speculative]
    [known] as a proposal: Deninger, “Some analogies between number theory and dynamical systems on foliated spaces,” Documenta Mathematica, Extra Volume ICM I (1998), 163–186; and “Analogies between…
  16. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Leafwise cohomology, the trace formula, and what RH would become [speculative]
    [known] as a proposed translation, not a theorem. Matching the explicit formula for ζ would require α = 1, hence Re ρ = 1/2. In the 1998 ICM address Deninger discusses this as a positivity or…
  17. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What is open [speculative]
    [speculative] Any claim that this picture “explains the zeros of ζ,” or that a positivity condition on a leafwise cohomology “is” the Riemann hypothesis, is speculative in the strict sense: the…
  18. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Sources Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  19. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A spectral model, with a qualification [speculative]
    [speculative] Deninger's arithmetic cohomology/foliation program seeks a flow and a positive pairing. Connes–Consani's arithmetic/scaling sites seek another geometric route to the explicit…
  20. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › What comes back from our six hypercomplex threads? [speculative]
    [speculative] A useful next search is position-sensitive: an operator, pairing, approximation theorem or factor identity whose ordinary slice is exactly a known ζ object. Prove its positivity or…
  21. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Which factor owns the zero? [speculative]
    [speculative] A new independent location or upper-count theorem could rule the model out. Merely adding fields, directions or symmetry does not. Derivation, stronger solvable-group budgets, source…
  22. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The notebook behind the tangent Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  23. Zeta zeros › The Hypothesis 20 figures Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  24. Method and status Speculative
    Every figure is computed here or taken from a cited table. Sentences carry a flag: Settled , Open , or Speculative .
  25. Method and status › Figures, and what they are not Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Full note above
  26. Open questions › Hypercomplex and order zetas: the project’s research queue Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  27. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A coin-flip walk over the whole numbers Speculative Heuristic only
    Speculative Heuristic only The coin-flip picture is a guide, not a theorem: μ(n) is completely determined by factoring, not random. It does predict the right √x scale, and under RH plus further…
  28. The Riemann Hypothesis: one conjecture about the zeros › A schematic of the plane Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  29. Sources › Data and computation Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  30. Statistics of the zeros › Closest calls: Lehmer pairs Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  31. Zeros and primes › Riemann’s R(x): a better smooth guess Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status
  32. Zeros on the critical line › Gram’s law at three heights Speculative
    Personal working notes. Computed figures and cited theorems. Nothing here proves the Riemann Hypothesis. Flags: Settled Open Speculative · Method and status

Known (213)

Established mathematics, cited to a source.

  1. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › More imaginary directions: the intrinsic construction [known]
    [known] An imaginary unit is a direction that squares to −1. Complex numbers have two choices, i and −i. Quaternions have a whole ordinary sphere of choices, mixing i, j and k. Octonions have a…
  2. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › More imaginary directions: the intrinsic construction [known]
    [known] The imaginary units are S⁰, S² and S⁶. The last drawing is symbolic, not a projection of all seven imaginary coordinates.
  3. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › More imaginary directions: the intrinsic construction [known]
    [known] Write a number as q = x + rI: real part x, imaginary size r, chosen imaginary direction I. Each fixed I gives an ordinary complex plane inside the larger space. Zeta has real coefficients,…
  4. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where ½ and the zeros go [known]
    [known] In the complex plane, Re q = ½ is a line. In quaternion space it is a three-dimensional flat hyperplane, and in octonion space it is seven-dimensional. A hyperplane is simply the flat set…
  5. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where ½ and the zeros go [known]
    [known] For the clean mirror, use completed xi , which removes zeta’s pole and trivial zeros. Its mirror law is ξ(1 − q̄) = ξ(q)̄: reflect the input through that hyperplane, and the output is…
  6. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 · Quaternion arithmetic: when the mirror forces a zero [known]
    [known] There is established arithmetic where quaternionic symmetry really does change the answer at the central point. The quaternion group Q₈ = {±1, ±i, ±j, ±k} can describe the Galois…
  7. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 · Quaternion arithmetic: when the mirror forces a zero [known]
    [known] Its two-dimensional quaternionic representation can produce a completed L-function with root number −1. A root number is the sign in its mirror equation. With that sign, the value at the…
  8. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 · Quaternion arithmetic: when the mirror forces a zero [known]
    [known] The curve illustrates odd symmetry, not a numerical computation of an Artin L-function. Quaternionic type alone does not force the negative sign; the arithmetic of the field matters.…
  9. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Not every “quaternion zeta” vanishes at ½ [known]
    [known] There is another arithmetic construction that counts ideals in a quaternion order—the analogue of integers inside a quaternion algebra. It is not the Artin L-function above. For the…
  10. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Change the arithmetic, keep the sign—with a condition [known]
    [known] A quadratic twist changes the weights attached to primes using a quadratic character. It is not a rotation from i toward j. Shankar–Södergren–Templier’s Proposition 8.7 proves that…
  11. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Twist the arithmetic twelve times: the forced zero stays simple [known]
    [known] Each negative-sign twist still has a forced central zero. The minus mirror makes its central multiplicity odd; it could be three or higher, rather than one. A nonzero certified derivative…
  12. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Real quaternion coefficients: the length is arithmetic, the direction is not [known]
    [known] In a field whose symmetry group is Q₈ = {±1, ±i, ±j, ±k}, the prime-by-prime symmetries (Frobenius elements) are literally quaternions. But each one is only defined up to a swap like i ↔…
  13. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] The group. Q8 has 8 unit quaternions. The next symmetric family has 24: ±1, ±i, ±j, ±k and the sixteen numbers (±1 ± i ± j ± k)/2. They form the binary tetrahedral group 2T (also called…
  14. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [project, proved] The aligned product, now with proved exponents. As for Q8, put the complex unit of s inside the quaternions, along the order-6 axis. The primes whose quaternion lies on that axis…
  15. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [project, proved] The line ½ is still a barrier, but a weaker one, and the power is now a theorem. The order-4 primes (a quarter of all primes) cannot lie on the chosen axis. Their axes meet it at…
  16. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] The tool. The explicit formula, in the form that does not assume an L-function is its own conjugate (Weil 1952; Iwaniec–Kowalski, Theorem 5.12), turns a sum over primes into a sum over…
  17. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    The 120-element group 2I gives a different answer. [project, float numerics] On the same degree-120 field (ramified only at 2, 11 and 23), with Frobenius quaternions now known at all 33 860…
  18. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [project, interval arithmetic, conditional] The exponent is 1/24. L(ρ, ½) and L(ρ′, ½) now have interval enclosures: 5.851618798 ± 1.2·10 −10 and 0.5132584851 ± 8.8·10 −11 . The simple zero of…
  19. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] The root number is a product of local signs, one for each prime and one for the real place, and for a character χ the local constants satisfy ε(χ)ε(χ⁻¹) = χ(−1) (Tate, Corvallis 1979).…
  20. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [project, interval arithmetic, conditional] Each forced zero is simple. Here ρ′ is the √5 → −√5 partner of ρ, and it also has root number −1. All four derivatives at ½ were enclosed with interval…
  21. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] [project, proved] The root number of Sym³ρ is +1, by a local argument. At the one ramified prime p the local group is abelian, so ρ splits there as two characters ψ and ψ⁻¹, and Sym³ρ…
  22. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] [project, proof sketch] Why the product is −1 here. The global root number is the product of local ones, and Tate’s rule ε(χ)ε(χ⁻¹) = χ(−1) handles each prime. At 701 the local group is…
  23. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] In plain words. Hardy’s sign changes and Levinson’s counting both start from a real-valued function on the line, which exists because the functional equation mirrors the plane across Re s…
  24. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] In plain words. A theorem of Andersen and Thorner says that for every “GL₂ newform” (a modular form, or its non-holomorphic cousin, a Maass form , on Γ₀(N) with trivial character), more…
  25. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] Why. ρ is built (“induced”) from a character ψ of a real quadratic field F. For such induced representations there is a matching newform with the same L-function. It is a Maass form with…
  26. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [known]
    [known] Every subfield is real and ρ is even (conjugation acts as ±1), so each L(ρ, s) is L(s, f) for a Hecke–Maass newform f of level 2304 or 42025 with trivial character, and κ > 0.0696 : more…
  27. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Quaternion orders: counting ideals changes the zeros [known]
    [known] Now change the arithmetic object, not the imaginary direction. A quaternion order is an integer-like lattice closed under multiplication. Its ideal zeta counts multiplication-compatible…
  28. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The missing zero at the middle [known consequence]
    [known consequence] At s = ½ the factor 1 − p 1−2s vanishes, but ζ(2s) has a pole. Their product has a finite, nonzero limit:
  29. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The whole real axis: a ladder of half-steps [known consequence]
    [known consequence] On the real line the zero map of these order zetas is complete and simple to state. ζ(2s) vanishes at s = −1, −2, −3, …; ζ(2s − 1) vanishes at s = −½, −3/2, −5/2, …. Together…
  30. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Inheritance, not interaction [known]
    [known] An ordinary zero ½ + iγ appears twice: once at ¼ + iγ/2, and once at ¾ + iγ/2. Both outer lines therefore have exactly the same heights , each half the ordinary height. These are inherited…
  31. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Inheritance, not interaction [known]
    [known] A ramified prime p supplies the middle-line heights πk / log p. For that one prime they are evenly spaced by π / log p . The D = 30 middle line mixes the p = 2, 3 and 5 progressions, so…
  32. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Inheritance, not interaction [known]
    [known] The horizontal separation is still ¼, even if two heights were exactly equal. The factorization superposes zero families; these nearby heights do not establish attraction, repulsion or any…
  33. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [known]
    [known] The inherited zeros need ordinary ζ at twice the height. Sign changes of Hardy’s real Z-function locate zeros. Turing’s average bound supplies the missing upper count: an overlooked zero…
  34. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [known]
    [known] The outer-line main term is (T/π) log(T/π) − T/π + 7/8. The middle-line main term is T log D / π. Its density is constant; the inherited density grows logarithmically. A sum of…
  35. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [known]
    [known] These functions explicitly contain shifted ζ factors. Platt–Trudgian already rigorously verified ordinary RH to about 3 × 10 12 , vastly beyond the ordinary height 2,000 needed here. This…
  36. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › What this does not say about RH [known]
    [known] The two outside lines are inherited from ζ(2s) and ζ(2s − 1). The middle line comes from elementary ramified-prime factors. Putting all inherited zeros on the quarter-lines, at every…
  37. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Nonmaximal quaternion orders: the Eichler comparison [known]
    [known] A quaternion order plays the role, inside a quaternion algebra, that the ordinary integers play inside the rational numbers. Its zeta function counts its ideals, the way ζ counts whole…
  38. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Counting all modules, not just invertible ones [open]
    [project · proved, refereed] The remaining coefficients and the mirror symmetry follow from the column-pair formula above. [open] A short search found this formula nowhere in the literature; that…
  39. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 4 · Those zeros are on the half-line too [known]
    [known] None of this is about the Riemann Hypothesis. The half-line results concern finite polynomials attached to one prime; RH concerns the infinitely many zeros of ζ itself, which these local…
  40. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 4 · Octonion orders: the prime 2 changes the count [known]
    [known] For Coxeter’s integral octonions (the E 8 lattice), every one-sided ideal is two-sided and of the form mO (Petersson, Integral octonions , 2018 notes, Thm. 1; van der Blij–Springer 1959;…
  41. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Every order between Z 8 and E 8 [known]
    [known] None of this is about the Riemann Hypothesis: these are finite local factors at one prime. Notes: ideal count · period-4 proof · intermediate order · all intermediate orders and the…
  42. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 is exceptional: what happens at 3, 5 and 7? [known]
    [known] All sixteen orders give the same answer at every odd prime. The extra half-coordinates that distinguish them matter at 2, but not at 3, 5 or 7. At an odd prime p, the only right ideals are…
  43. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 is exceptional: what happens at 3, 5 and 7? [known]
    [known] Its numerator is 1: no local zeros anywhere, including on Re s = ½. The empty panels below are an exact answer, not zeros we failed to find. The function has poles instead, all on Re s =…
  44. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 is exceptional: what happens at 3, 5 and 7? [known]
    [known] [project, computer-assisted] At odd primes the local numerator is 1: the empty panels are the answer. Prime-2 dots are earlier project results. Heights use Im(s)log(p)/(2π), normalized…
  45. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 is exceptional: what happens at 3, 5 and 7? [known]
    [known] Why this is settled, not a guess. Petersson, Norm equivalences and ideals of composition algebras (2021), Theorem 4.1(i), proves that every one-sided ideal of an octonion composition…
  46. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 is exceptional: what happens at 3, 5 and 7? [known]
    [known] Zero-free local factors do not make the continued global zeta zero-free: ζ(8s) itself has these factors and inherits the ordinary zeta zeros. There is no RH claim. Full definitions,…
  47. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [known]
    [known] All four functions have infinitely many inherited zeros on Re s = 1/16. Saying every inherited nontrivial zero is on that line would require RH. The 102 inherited zeros shown below,…
  48. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [known]
    [known] E 8 does. The usual completed zeta function satisfies ξ(w) = ξ(1−w). Set w = 8s: ξ(8s) reflects s ↦ 1/8−s, so its center is 1/16 . Explicitly its completion multiplies the raw count by…
  49. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [open]
    [open] This rules out the usual rescaled-zeta completion, not every imaginable completion . Adding missing mirror factors can manufacture a symmetric function, but introduces extra zeros; dividing…
  50. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [open]
    [known / project] Bushnell–Reiner’s 1980 Theorem 2 and remarks, pp. 156–158, were re-read for this comparison. Their Fourier/contragredient argument uses associative orders and a simple…
  51. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Why are octonion orders strange at 2? [known]
    How this reaches the zeta factor—and where it stops. Right ideals in S/2S lift precisely to ideals I with 2S ⊆ I ⊆ S . They see just one layer of the 2-adic ideal tree. At index 32, G has 7 ideals…
  52. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Why are octonion orders strange at 2? [known; source access stated]
    [known; source access stated] Petersson’s Integral octonions , printed pp. 2–3 , actually read, explains Coxeter/Bruck’s correction of Kirmse’s lattice and the nonorthogonal half-coordinate…
  53. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Square it: a sphere becomes a number [known]
    [known] Xi’s symmetry lets us write ξ(q) = E((q − ½)²), with E an ordinary entire function whose Taylor coefficients are positive. RH is equivalent to every zero of E being negative real. This is…
  54. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Square it: a sphere becomes a number [known]
    [known] The stronger positivity condition is total positivity : all minors of a certain matrix made from those coefficients must be nonnegative, at every size. Ordinary positive coefficients and…
  55. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The finite sphere: ordinary linking [known]
    [known] A round two-dimensional sphere in four-dimensional space leaves room for a loop to link it. The same is true for a round six-dimensional sphere in eight-dimensional space: each has two…
  56. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Watch two spheres collide and leave the critical plane [known]
    [known] The de Bruijn–Newman deformation gives a real analytic version of zero collisions under a backwards heat equation. Rodgers and Tao proved its threshold Λ is nonnegative. RH is equivalent…
  57. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › What happens to the rest of the toolkit? [known/speculative]
    [known/speculative] Quaternion rotations do involve half-angles. No established link makes that ½ explain the zeta critical line. Matching symbols is not a theorem.
  58. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where octonions actually behave differently [known]
    [known] Octonions lose associativity: (ab)c need not equal a(bc). Zeta never tests that fault line, because its real coefficients keep each evaluation inside a single complex plane. Even the…
  59. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where octonions actually behave differently [known · checked example]
    [known · checked example] Use three directions that do not fit in one associative subalgebra. Ghiloni and Perotti’s Remark 3 gives f(w) = we₁ − e₂ and a constant e₄ outside the quaternionic…
  60. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › E₈: a real lattice difference, and a different mirror centre [known]
    [known] Define the lattice Epstein zeta by summing |v| −2s over nonzero lattice points v; |v| means distance from the origin. A self-dual lattice is one whose associated reciprocal grid matches…
  61. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Do zeros move? Movement, phase and duality [known]
    [known] Can a zero of one family move into the other? In one fixed zeta function, nothing moves. Its zeros come from its factors; a shared zero contributes the sum of their multiplicities. Motion…
  62. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Do zeros move? Movement, phase and duality [known]
    [known] The multiplicative dial slides a whole local column rigidly; heights do not change.
  63. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary computational data]
    [known · primary computational data] LMFDB Artin representations 2.2304.8t5.b.a and 2.2304.8t5.a.a : both original records opened and independently checked. PARI 2.17.2 supplies Artin…
  64. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary]
    [known · primary] Armitage, Zeta functions with a zero at s = ½ (1972); Fröhlich, Artin-root numbers and normal integral bases for quaternion fields (1972). Original records checked; full scans…
  65. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary]
    [known · primary] Alexander, An example of a simply connected surface bounding a region which is not simply connected (1924); Łojasiewicz, Triangulation of semi-analytic sets (1964). The…
  66. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary]
    [known · primary] Ghiloni–Perotti, Zeros of regular functions of quaternionic and octonionic variable (2009 preprint): spherical and isolated zeros, the normal function, and the octonionic…
  67. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary]
    [known · primary] Ghiloni–Perotti, Slice regular functions on real alternative algebras (2011); Gentili–Stoppato–Struppa, Regular Functions of a Quaternionic Variable (2013). Framework references;…
  68. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary]
    [known · primary] Eilenberg–Niven, The “fundamental theorem of algebra” for quaternions (1944). The octonionic claims above use the later Ghiloni–Perotti framework, not this paper alone.
  69. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary]
    [known · primary] Aissen–Edrei–Schoenberg–Whitney, On the generating functions of totally positive sequences (1951); Turing, Some calculations of the Riemann zeta-function (1953).
  70. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary]
    [known · primary] de Bruijn, The roots of trigonometric integrals (1950); Rodgers–Tao, The de Bruijn–Newman constant is non-negative (2018 preprint; published 2020). The latter’s heat-flow…
  71. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [known · primary]
    [known · primary] Riesz, Sur l’hypothèse de Riemann (1916); Littlewood (1912), the Mertens growth criterion . Source-access limits and additional Li/Jensen references are in the notebook.
  72. How much of the critical line can we prove? [known]
    [known] How to read the labels. Every claim carries one tag. [known] is published mathematics, with the source named (full list in the sources ). [project] is something we computed or checked…
  73. How much of the critical line can we prove? [known]
    [known] How to read the labels. Every claim carries one tag. [known] is published mathematics, with the source named (full list in the sources ). [project] is something we computed or checked…
  74. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 0. The answer in one paragraph [known]
    The non-trivial zeros of ζ(s) come in mirror pairs across the vertical line Re s = ½, unless a zero sits exactly on that line [known] the functional equation ξ(s) = ξ(1 − s); Iwaniec (17.1)–(17.3)…
  75. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 0. The answer in one paragraph [known]
    The non-trivial zeros of ζ(s) come in mirror pairs across the vertical line Re s = ½, unless a zero sits exactly on that line [known] the functional equation ξ(s) = ξ(1 − s); Iwaniec (17.1)–(17.3)…
  76. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 0. The answer in one paragraph [known]
    The non-trivial zeros of ζ(s) come in mirror pairs across the vertical line Re s = ½, unless a zero sits exactly on that line [known] the functional equation ξ(s) = ξ(1 − s); Iwaniec (17.1)–(17.3)…
  77. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 0. The answer in one paragraph [known]
    Selberg (1942) looks for zeros on the line directly, as sign changes of a real function, after "taming" the function with a correcting factor called a mollifier . It proves that a positive…
  78. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 0. The answer in one paragraph [known]
    Levinson (1974) does the opposite: he counts the zeros of a related function G that are off the line on the right-hand side, shows there are few of them, and subtracts. With a mollifier again,…
  79. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 0. The answer in one paragraph [known]
    Computers have checked that every zero up to height 3·10¹² is on the line [known] Platt–Trudgian 2021, as cited in Knausgård 2026 §1 . That does not prove any fraction "in the long run": the…
  80. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 1. The ladder of proved fractions [known]
    PRZZ 2020 is the record for the mollifier method (κ > 0.417293) [known] PRZZ 2020, Res. Math. Sci. 7 . It is not the only kind of result any more — see the box.
  81. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 2. Hardy's Z(t): a zero on the line is a sign change [known]
    Then Z(t) is real for real t and |Z(t)| = |ζ(½ + it)| [known] Titchmarsh ch. X; Iwaniec (15.2)–(15.4); it follows from the functional equation . Z is continuous, so if Z(a) > 0 and Z(b) < 0 there…
  82. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 2. Hardy's Z(t): a zero on the line is a sign change [known]
    Then Z(t) is real for real t and |Z(t)| = |ζ(½ + it)| [known] Titchmarsh ch. X; Iwaniec (15.2)–(15.4); it follows from the functional equation . Z is continuous, so if Z(a) > 0 and Z(b) < 0 there…
  83. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 2. Hardy's Z(t): a zero on the line is a sign change [known]
    Hardy's 1914 idea. Hardy did not yet have a way to count sign changes. He showed there are infinitely many by contradiction: he wrote an integral of Ξ (essentially Z, with the Gamma factor…
  84. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 3. Hardy–Littlewood (1921): sign changes in windows, and why that gives only ≫ T [known]
    The mechanism [known] Iwaniec ch. 15, Thm 15.1 and Lemma 15.2; Titchmarsh §§10.5–10.7 . Put
  85. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 3. Hardy–Littlewood (1921): sign changes in windows, and why that gives only ≫ T [known]
    Comparing the two, the set of t where |I| = J has measure ≪ T/Δ. Take Δ to be a large constant: most of [T, 2T] is covered by windows that must contain a sign change, and packing disjoint ones…
  86. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 3. Hardy–Littlewood (1921): sign changes in windows, and why that gives only ≫ T [known]
    Why this is not a positive fraction. N(T) grows like T log T, but fixed-length windows can certify only about one zero per window, i.e. about T/Δ zeros: a vanishing fraction (about 1/log T) of all…
  87. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 3. Hardy–Littlewood (1921): sign changes in windows, and why that gives only ≫ T [known]
    Why this is not a positive fraction. N(T) grows like T log T, but fixed-length windows can certify only about one zero per window, i.e. about T/Δ zeros: a vanishing fraction (about 1/log T) of all…
  88. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [known]
    The problem. Averages of |ζ(½ + it)|² are dominated by rare spikes: the mean square up to T grows like log T, while a typical value is much smaller [known] Iwaniec ch. 16; the source notes .…
  89. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [known]
    The fix. Multiply ζ by a short finite sum M(s) = Σ n ≤ y a(n) n −s (a Dirichlet polynomial ) chosen to approximate 1/ζ(s). Then ζ·M is close to 1 most of the time, so its averages are no longer…
  90. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [known]
    so a(1) = 1 and the coefficients fade out as n approaches y [known] Levinson P(x) = x; Conrey 1983/1989 general P; Young eq. for ψ; Iwaniec (23.7) . Selberg's version is the square of a smoothed…
  91. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [known]
    so a(1) = 1 and the coefficients fade out as n approaches y [known] Levinson P(x) = x; Conrey 1983/1989 general P; Young eq. for ψ; Iwaniec (23.7) . Selberg's version is the square of a smoothed…
  92. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [known]
    The length. y = T θ . θ is the single most important parameter: a longer mollifier imitates 1/ζ better. But the averages of |ζM|² can only be proved when θ is below a barrier set by how well one…
  93. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    The mechanism , as written out in Titchmarsh §§10.9–10.22 (Theorem 10.22 is Selberg's theorem; Titchmarsh follows Selberg's method). Selberg's own 59-page paper (Skr. Norske Vid. Akad. Oslo 1942…
  94. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    The mollifier. Let α_ν be the coefficients of ζ(s) −1/2 (so α₁ = 1), taper them as β_ν = α_ν (1 − log ν / log X) for ν < X, and put φ(s) = Σ β_ν ν −s . The weight is |φ(½ + it)|², a smoothed…
  95. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    The real function. Titchmarsh works with a real function F(t), built from Ξ(t) times |φ(½ + it)|² times explicit smooth factors; on the line it has the sign of Z(t) and size about t −1/4 e −δt/2…
  96. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    Two kinds of mean square — the heart of the proof [known] Titchmarsh Lemmas 10.17–10.21 :
  97. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    The good set has positive density. Let E be the set of t in (0, T) where ∫ t t+h |F| > |∫ t t+h F| — on E the function F changes sign inside (t, t + h). Off E the two integrals agree, so all the…
  98. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    From windows to zeros. Split (0, T) into intervals (nh, (n+1)h). Since m(E) > A₃T, at least [A₃T/h] of them meet E; each forces a zero of ζ(½ + iu) in (nh, (n+2)h), and each zero is counted at…
  99. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    Why the fraction is tiny. Every step loses a constant: Cauchy–Schwarz, the comparison of moments, the factor ½ from double counting, and the fact that a window holding two zeros still counts once…
  100. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    Why the fraction is tiny. Every step loses a constant: Cauchy–Schwarz, the comparison of moments, the factor ½ from double counting, and the fact that a window holding two zeros still counts once…
  101. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [known]
    Iwaniec calls Selberg's route "safe": it can never produce a negative bound, only a small one [known] Iwaniec ch. 16 .
  102. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    Step A — a mirror identity [known] Iwaniec (17.4)–(17.7) . Write ξ(s) = H(s)ζ(s) with H(s) = ½ s(1 − s) π −s/2 Γ(s/2), so ξ(s) = ξ(1 − s). Put G = ζ + λζ′ (λ real). Then
  103. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    [project] identity re-derived by hand — the ξ′ terms cancel because ξ′(1 − s) = −ξ′(s). On the line, 1 − s is the complex conjugate of s and everything has real coefficients, so the right side is…
  104. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    Step B — the angle must turn; zeros of G on the right absorb turning [known] Iwaniec ch. 19, (19.14) . Between heights T and T + U the number of crossings is at least (1/π)·(total change of arg…
  105. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    or in Conrey's words: "if the proportion of zeros of [G] to the right of the critical line is ≤ p, then the proportion of zeros of ζ on the critical line is ≥ 1 − 2p" [known] Conrey 1989 §1 . The…
  106. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    or in Conrey's words: "if the proportion of zeros of [G] to the right of the critical line is ≤ p, then the proportion of zeros of ζ on the critical line is ≥ 1 − 2p" [known] Conrey 1989 §1 . The…
  107. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    Step C — Littlewood's lemma on a box with left edge a = ½ − R/log T [known] Iwaniec ch. 20–21, (20.9), (21.1)–(22.1); Conrey 1989 (37) . Multiply G by a mollifier M (this only adds zeros, so an…
  108. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    and the other three edges contribute only O(U/log T). The left edge sits slightly left of ½, at a = ½ − R/log T, as a buffer : every zero on or right of the line is then at distance at least R/log…
  109. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    Step D — concavity: the average of log is at most the log of the average [known] Iwaniec Thm 22.1; Conrey 1989 (38); Young (1.1) . (1/U)∫ log|F| = ½(1/U)∫ log|F|² ≤ ½ log((1/U)∫|F|²). Putting this…
  110. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    Step E — one mean value [known] Young Thm 1 and Lemma 5; Iwaniec ch. 23–27; Conrey 1989 §§3–4 . With M(s) = Σ h ≤ T θ μ(h) h −(s + ½ − a) P(log(T θ /h)/log T θ ), the mean square tends to an…
  111. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    so κ ≥ 1 − (log c)/R: everything reduces to a double integral. Levinson's choices (P(x) = x, Q(x) = 1 − x, R = 1.3, θ = ½) give c ≈ 2.35 and κ ≥ 0.34 [known] Young . The hard part is proving the…
  112. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [known]
    so κ ≥ 1 − (log c)/R: everything reduces to a double integral. Levinson's choices (P(x) = x, Q(x) = 1 − x, R = 1.3, θ = ½) give c ≈ 2.35 and κ ≥ 0.34 [known] Young . The hard part is proving the…
  113. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [known]
    Why θ is capped. In the expanded mean square, an off-diagonal term oscillates like (hm/kn) it . With h, k ≤ T θ and m, n ≲ T, two different integers hm ≠ kn are far enough apart that integrating…
  114. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [known]
    Why θ is capped. In the expanded mean square, an off-diagonal term oscillates like (hm/kn) it . With h, k ≤ T θ and m, n ≲ T, two different integers hm ≠ kn are far enough apart that integrating…
  115. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [known]
    Why θ is capped. In the expanded mean square, an off-diagonal term oscillates like (hm/kn) it . With h, k ≤ T θ and m, n ≲ T, two different integers hm ≠ kn are far enough apart that integrating…
  116. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [known]
    The ratio 0.34744/0.34274 ≈ 1.014 matches the "only 1.4%" improvement in Levinson's 1975 PNAS abstract [project] consistent with sources . Conrey's 0.4077/0.4088 at θ = 4/7 is higher than our…
  117. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [known]
    Past 4/7 — formula only, no theorem [project] . Evaluating the same formula at θ = 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0 gives 0.419, 0.471, 0.516, 0.554, 0.5866 . These are not theorems: for ζ itself no mean…
  118. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [known]
    Past 4/7 — formula only, no theorem [project] . Evaluating the same formula at θ = 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0 gives 0.419, 0.471, 0.516, 0.554, 0.5866 . These are not theorems: for ζ itself no mean…
  119. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 8. What these methods do not give [known]
    A lower bound for a proportion in the long run (a liminf as T → ∞). Nothing about any particular finite stretch; and conversely finite computations (all zeros to height 3·10¹² on the line) say…
  120. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 8. What these methods do not give [known]
    Constant losses at every step — Cauchy–Schwarz and double counting for Selberg; the factor 2 in Step B, the buffer (the 1/R), and concavity for Levinson. The records come from better G, better M…
  121. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 8. What these methods do not give [known]
    No route to 100%. No version of Levinson's method is expected to reach 1 [known] PRZZ 2020 intro , and none of this is progress on RH.
  122. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 8. What these methods do not give [known]
    Selberg's and Levinson's methods are "diametrically opposed" (Conrey's comparison, quoted in PRZZ §1): Selberg counts on-line zeros directly and can never give a negative bound; Levinson counts…
  123. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 9. Worked example: Z(t) sign changes versus N(T) up to height 2000 [known]
    Sign changes on a fine grid = N(T) at every checkpoint: every zero up to 2000 shows up as a sign change of Z, i.e. is on the line and simple. This is long known — Gram 1903 (15 zeros), Backlund…
  124. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [known]
    10.1 The classical Q8 Artin L-function L(ρ, s). Here K/ℚ is Galois with group Q8 and ρ is its 2-dimensional faithful representation; L(ρ, s) equals a Hecke L-function L(F, ψ, s) of a quadratic…
  125. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [known]
    Selberg's method has been carried over to degree-2 L-functions: Hafner proved N₀(T) > A T log T for L-functions of Hecke eigenforms of even weight on the full modular group, using a mollifier that…
  126. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [known]
    Selberg's method has been carried over to degree-2 L-functions: Hafner proved N₀(T) > A T log T for L-functions of Hecke eigenforms of even weight on the full modular group, using a mollifier that…
  127. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [known]
    Levinson's method has been carried over too, with an explicit share. Andersen and Thorner prove that for any holomorphic or Hecke–Maass newform f on Γ₀(N) with trivial nebentypus, more than 6.96%…
  128. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [known]
    Does that cover our L(ρ, s)? Yes. Update 12 November 2026: the standard step is now cited and checked ( Q₈ Artin L-function as a Maass newform ). The original reasoning follows. Here ρ is even…
  129. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [known]
    Levinson's Steps A–D are pure algebra and complex analysis for any L-function with this kind of functional equation [project] elementary: the Step A algebra used only ξ(s) = ξ(1 − s) and real…
  130. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 11. Figures and computations used here
    All four figures above are drawn from the computations below, each run twice by independent programs unless stated. The scripts and their outputs are in the research folder; start with em_numpy.py…
  131. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture [known]
    [known] How to read the labels. Every claim carries one tag. [known] is published mathematics, with the source named (full list in the sources and in the primer ). [project] is a figure or check…
  132. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture [known]
    [known] How to read the labels. Every claim carries one tag. [known] is published mathematics, with the source named (full list in the sources and in the primer ). [project] is a figure or check…
  133. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What is a foliation? [known]
    [known] Imagine a manifold — a space that looks locally like ordinary Euclidean space of some dimension n — cut into a family of thinner pieces, all of the same dimension p, that fit together…
  134. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Example: the Kronecker foliation of the torus [known]
    [known] Let T 2 be the two-torus, drawn as the unit square with opposite sides glued. Fix a slope α, and take the lines of that slope in the plane, then descend them to the torus. If α is…
  135. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Example: the Kronecker foliation of the torus [known]
    [known] The Kronecker (linear) foliation of the torus. Opposite sides of the square are glued, as the matching ticks show. If the slope α is irrational, a single leaf is dense; if α is rational,…
  136. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Example: the Reeb foliation of the solid torus [known]
    [known] The Reeb foliation of the solid torus D 2 × S 1 (Reeb, 1952) has a single compact leaf — the boundary torus — and every interior leaf is a plane, winding and accumulating on that boundary.…
  137. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Example: the Reeb foliation of the solid torus [known]
    [known] Left: a meridional disk. The heavy outer circle is the trace of the compact boundary leaf; the interior curves are traces of plane leaves, accumulating on the boundary. Right: a schematic…
  138. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Example: foliations by level sets [known]
    [known] If f is a smooth real-valued function whose derivative never vanishes, the level sets f −1 (c) are a foliation of codimension one. If the derivative is allowed to vanish, those zeros are…
  139. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Singular points, and zeros of a vector field [known]
    [known] A regular foliation has a leaf through every point, all of the same dimension. Many naturally occurring “foliations” are allowed to have singular points, where a defining vector field or…
  140. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Singular points, and zeros of a vector field [known]
    [known] Four linear types of isolated zero in the plane. The saddle has index −1; the node, the focus and the centre have index +1. Poincaré–Hopf: on a compact oriented manifold, the sum of the…
  141. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Holomorphic foliations: Seidenberg reduction and the Camacho–Sad index [known]
    [known] In complex dimension two the natural object is a holomorphic foliation , given locally by a holomorphic vector field, or by a holomorphic 1-form ω = A dx + B dy. A singularity is a point…
  142. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Deninger’s proposed dictionary [known]
    [known] as a proposal. In a series of papers beginning with a 1992/1994 motives paper and set out for a general audience in the 1998 ICM address and a 2008 survey, Christopher Deninger has…
  143. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Deninger’s proposed dictionary [known]
    [known] as a proposal: Deninger, “Some analogies between number theory and dynamical systems on foliated spaces,” Documenta Mathematica, Extra Volume ICM I (1998), 163–186; and “Analogies between…
  144. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Leafwise cohomology, the trace formula, and what RH would become [known]
    [known] On a foliated space one can differentiate only in the leaf direction. The resulting de Rham complex along the leaves has a reduced leafwise cohomology Ḧ • F (X). Álvarez López and…
  145. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Leafwise cohomology, the trace formula, and what RH would become [known]
    [known] Under strong conformal hypotheses on a compact 3-manifold, a transversal index theorem of Álvarez López–Kordyukov and Deninger–Singhof gives a distributional identity of the same shape as…
  146. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Leafwise cohomology, the trace formula, and what RH would become [known]
    [known] as a proposed translation, not a theorem. Matching the explicit formula for ζ would require α = 1, hence Re ρ = 1/2. In the 1998 ICM address Deninger discusses this as a positivity or…
  147. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › A related picture, which is not the same [known]
    [known] Alain Connes’ 1999 Selecta paper constructs a spectral realization of the zeros of ζ as an absorption spectrum of an operator on an adelic space, in the language of noncommutative…
  148. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [known]
    [known] Take a circle of length L = log q, and let time act on it by rotation at unit speed. This is the simplest possible “flow on a space,” and it has exactly one closed orbit, of length log q.…
  149. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [known]
    [known] The proof uses three standard facts: ζ H (0, a) = ½ − a, ζ H ′(0, a) = log(Γ(a)/√(2π)), and the reflection formula Γ(z)Γ(1 − z) = π / sin(πz). Put together, they give 2 sin(πα) e iπ(α −…
  150. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [known]
    [known] The curve 1 − 2 −s , the regularized determinant of s − θ for q = 2. [project] The sample points mark where the Arb enclosure of the difference contained zero.
  151. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [known]
    [known] The leading coefficient. The Ruelle zeta function of this flow is ζ R (s) = 1 / (1 − q −s ). Near s = 0 we have 1 − q −s = s log q − …, so ζ R has a simple pole at s = 0, and s · ζ R (s)…
  152. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [known]
    [known] s · ζ R (s) → 1 / log q as s → 0. [project] Values at s = ±10 −k are plotted, and the gap to 1 / log q is about s / 2.
  153. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Counting zeros of a vector field: three Poincaré–Hopf examples [known]
    [known] Poincaré–Hopf says: draw a vector field with finitely many zeros on a closed surface, assign each zero its index (+1 for a source, sink or centre, −1 for a saddle, in the simple cases),…
  154. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Counting zeros of a vector field: three Poincaré–Hopf examples [known]
    [known] Poincaré–Hopf: the sum of the indices of the zeros equals the Euler characteristic of the surface. [project] The three fields drawn here were checked numerically and their indices…
  155. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Closed orbits and closed points: bookkeeping for an elliptic curve over a finite field [known]
    [known] This is the one place where Deninger’s dictionary is carried out in full. Let E be an elliptic curve over a finite field with q elements. A closed point of E is an orbit of the Frobenius…
  156. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Closed orbits and closed points: bookkeeping for an elliptic curve over a finite field [known]
    [known] Closed points of E over F q correspond to Frobenius orbits, with length |o| · log q. [project] The counts P n for y 2 = x 3 + 1 over F 5 were computed and checked against the Euler product.
  157. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Closed orbits and closed points: bookkeeping for an elliptic curve over a finite field [known]
    [known] The leading coefficient here is also elementary: lim s→0 s · ζ E (s) = N 1 / ((1 − q) log q), from the simple pole of the rational function at T = 1. It is the analogue of the 1 / log q on…
  158. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The setup, in plain words [known]
    [known] Work in two complex variables x and y, and take the vector field X = λ 1 x ∂/∂x + λ 2 y ∂/∂y, where λ 1 and λ 2 are nonzero complex numbers. Its only zero is the origin. Its leaves are the…
  159. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Three results [known]
    [known] Index of an axis. For X = λ 1 x ∂ x + λ 2 y ∂ y , the index of {y = 0} at the origin is CS = λ 2 /λ 1 , and the index of {x = 0} is λ 1 /λ 2 (Camacho–Sad 1982). [project] We confirmed both…
  160. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Three results [known]
    [known] Blowing up the origin. A blow-up replaces the origin by a whole line E (the set of directions through it) and keeps everything else. E has self-intersection E·E = −1. The foliation now has…
  161. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Three results [known]
    [known] Camacho–Sad indices before and after one blow-up of the origin. [project] The two indices on E sum to −1 = E·E for every choice of λ 1 ≠ λ 2 we tried, symbolic and numerical.
  162. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › A convention caveat [known]
    [known] Sign convention: to be checked against the book. Signs and orientations in the Camacho–Sad index differ between sources, so this matters. The convention used above, which is recalled from…
  163. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Reduced versus resonant: a correction [known]
    [known] A singular point of a foliation is called reduced (in Seidenberg’s sense) when the linear part of the vector field has eigenvalues λ 1 , λ 2 that are not both zero and whose ratio is not a…
  164. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Reduced versus resonant: a correction [known]
    [known] This illustrates why Seidenberg’s reduction is needed: a non-reduced point cannot be understood from its linear part alone, and one has to blow up until the model is reduced. It…
  165. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The statement [known]
    [known] Let X = ℝ/(log q)ℤ be a circle of length log q, and let the flow translate it at unit speed, so θ = d/dx. Its eigenfunctions are e 2πiνx/log q for ν ∈ ℤ, with eigenvalue 2πiν/log q. Its…
  166. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The statement [known]
    [known] This is exactly the Poisson summation formula, Σ ν ĥ(2πν/T) = T · Σ k h(kT), with the period T = log q. The left side is the eigenvalue side : one term per eigenfunction. The right side is…
  167. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › A compactly supported check [known]
    [known] The same number computed two ways, for the Gaussian h(x) = exp(−x²/2) and q = 5. [project] Left: values of h at the orbit lengths k log 5 (orange), times log 5. Right: values of ĥ at the…
  168. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What has actually been built [known]
    The following items are theorems, or fully written constructions, in the papers cited. They are [known] .
  169. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What has actually been built [known]
    [known] The formal dictionary and the cohomological wish-list in Deninger 1994, 1998, 2001 and 2008. A precise proposal, not a construction of the arithmetic cohomology.
  170. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What has actually been built [known]
    [known] Function fields, and elliptic curves over finite fields. For a scheme over a finite field one can suspend a discrete Frobenius action to a flow, and closed orbits correspond to closed…
  171. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What has actually been built [known]
    [known] Leafwise Hodge theory for Riemannian foliations (Álvarez López–Kordyukov, 2001), and a transversal index theorem under strong hypotheses (Álvarez López–Kordyukov; Deninger–Singhof), with…
  172. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What has actually been built [known]
    [known] Kopei’s product formula for functions meromorphic along the leaves of a three-dimensional foliated flow, the dynamical counterpart of the product formula for a number field.
  173. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What has actually been built [known]
    [known] A Lichtenbaum analogue for a simple class of isometric flows, assuming regularized determinants exist (Deninger, arXiv:math/0605724), identified with analytic and Reidemeister torsion.
  174. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What has actually been built [known]
    [known] The circle, as a complete toy. On the circle R / (log q) Z, foliated by points, with R acting by translation, the Ruelle zeta is (1 − q −s ) −1 , and Lerch’s formula gives the regularized…
  175. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What has actually been built [known]
    [known] Leichtnam’s Lefschetz formula for laminated spaces with a p-adic transversal. Under his hypotheses, eigenvalues of θ on a degree-one group have real part 1/2. He states that the existence…
  176. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › What is open [known]
    [known] as open problems stated by the authors themselves.
  177. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A return ticket, not just another dimension [known]
    [known] Ordinary RH says every nontrivial zero of ζ(s) sits halfway across its critical strip. Those zeros influence the fluctuations of primes on the positive number line. A theorem about a…
  178. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Containment [known]
    [known] F=ζ×G, with G holomorphic. An ordinary zero cannot disappear. A zero-free theorem for F therefore constrains ζ.
  179. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Exact reformulation [known]
    [known] Prove all the required positivity or approximation conditions, and a known equivalence returns RH.
  180. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A controlled limit [known]
    [known] Locally uniform zero-free approximants have a zero-free limit unless that limit vanishes identically: Hurwitz's theorem.
  181. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The larger field really contains ordinary zeta [known]
    [known] Our Q₈ field is a genuine eight-degree extension of the rationals. Its zeta factors as
  182. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The larger field really contains ordinary zeta [known]
    [known] The Aramata–Brauer theorem makes ζ K /ζ entire for a Galois extension. No pole can cancel an ordinary-zeta zero. RH for the whole field function would imply ordinary RH. So would a…
  183. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The larger field really contains ordinary zeta [known]
    [known] The arrow is one-way. The Artin factor is forced to vanish at ½; the field function therefore vanishes there twice. Ordinary ζ(½)≈−1.46035 is not zero. A larger zero need not be a smaller…
  184. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Tensoring gives another honest bridge [known]
    [known] For this Q₈ representation, ρ⊗ρ* splits as the trivial character plus the three quadratic characters. Its L-function contains ζ. Odd tensor powers just repeat ρ; even powers contain ζ. The…
  185. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Tensoring gives another honest bridge [known]
    [known] Tensoring combines prime-by-prime arithmetic eigenvalues—not old zero locations. Knowing every zero of L(s,ρ) would not by itself give the tensor L-function's zeros. Gelbart–Jacquet and…
  186. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Where RH really is a theorem [known]
    [known] Over a finite field, counting points on a smooth projective curve produces a different zeta function. Hasse and Weil proved its zeros lie on a circle. Frobenius is a real geometric…
  187. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Turn Frobenius; keep its proven radius [known]
    [known] Deligne proved the finite-field theorem in every dimension . Cohomology separates the weights; the trace formula identifies Frobenius; geometric and monodromy methods prove the bounds.…
  188. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A spectral model, with a qualification [known]
    [known] For compact hyperbolic surfaces, the nontrivial spectral zeros of Selberg zeta satisfy s(1−s)=λ for Laplace eigenvalues λ. A self-adjoint Laplacian makes λ real. Values λ≥¼ give the…
  189. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › E₈: the mirror centre has no zeros at all [known]
    [known] The E₈ lattice zeta factors as 240·2 −s ζ(s)ζ(s−3). Its mirror is centred at 2. Yet the whole centre line is unconditionally zero-free, as is the open band between real parts 1 and 3. On…
  190. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › E₈: the mirror centre has no zeros at all [known]
    [known] So proving every nonreal E₈ zero lies on ½ or 3½ would imply ordinary RH. But mirror symmetry alone does not do it. At the centre, the completed value is −5/6; the raw continued lattice…
  191. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › E₈: the mirror centre has no zeros at all [known]
    [known] The quaternion ideal-index zeta gives a different exact bridge: ζ(2s)ζ(2s−1) times finite factors. All its nonreal zeros lying on ¼, ½ or ¾ is equivalent to ordinary RH. This is not the…
  192. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › E₈: the mirror centre has no zeros at all [known]
    [known] A genuinely higher-dimensional arithmetic scheme can be equally explicit: the zeta of projective n-space over the integers is ζ(s)ζ(s−1)…ζ(s−n). It contains ordinary ζ, but repeated shifts…
  193. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A statistical match is not a zero-by-zero implication [known]
    [known] Higher-rank GL(n) L-functions and random-matrix models give rich zero statistics. Montgomery and Rudnick–Sarnak proved correlation results under restricted hypotheses and Fourier support.…
  194. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A statistical match is not a zero-by-zero implication [known]
    [known] Even a perfect limiting bulk law can miss finitely many exceptional zeros. A universal claim about every real part needs a stronger bridge than an averaged histogram. Katz–Sarnak's author…
  195. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Li coefficients [known]
    [known] Every coefficient nonnegative ⇔ RH. Twenty or 500 positive coefficients is not “every”. In our field, coefficients add across factors; a positive total at one index does not imply positive…
  196. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Weil positivity [known]
    [known] The right explicit-formula pairing is positive on every admissible test square ⇔ RH. A finite positive matrix, or an unrelated squared norm, is not that universal theorem.
  197. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Nyman–Beurling [known]
    [known] A specified approximation problem in a Hilbert space has error tending to zero ⇔ RH. One finite error bound weakens as zero height grows; a genuine convergent sequence would reach every…
  198. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › de Bruijn–Newman flow [known]
    [known] An extra time parameter moves the zeros. All are real exactly above a threshold Λ. Rodgers–Tao proved Λ≥0; RH is now equivalent to Λ=0. A positive-time success need not run backwards.
  199. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Jensen polynomials [known]
    [known] The full real-rootedness criterion is equivalent to RH. Fixed-degree eventual real-rootedness is proved, but is not uniform control of every degree and shift. The quantifiers matter.
  200. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A bigger family that already ruled out a whole line [known]
    [known] This is not all hypothetical. A classical inequality couples three shifted values of ordinary ζ: ζ(σ)³|ζ(σ+it)|⁴|ζ(σ+2it)|≥1 for σ>1. Its Euler-product terms are nonnegative because 3+4cos…
  201. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A bigger family that already ruled out a whole line [known]
    [known] If ζ vanished at 1+it, the fourth-power zero would overpower the third-power pole as σ approached 1. The product would tend to zero, contradicting the lower bound. So Re(s)=1 is zero-free.…
  202. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Two return tickets turn out to share a matrix [known]
    [known] Lagarias gives an exact identity : certain Weil pairings equal λₙ+λₘ−λ |n−m| , where λ denotes Li coefficients. Positivity of every such finite compression is one way to organize the…
  203. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A finite approximation that really constrains every zero [known]
    [known] In the tail-cancelled Nyman–Beurling formulation, an off-line zero β+it with β>½ prevents a chosen approximant's squared L² error from falling below (2β−1)/(β²+t²). The Mellin transform…
  204. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A finite approximation that really constrains every zero [known]
    [known] A sequence of rigorous errors tending to zero would exclude every fixed off-line zero. The infinite-dimensional statement is essential: the weakening at large height is visible in the…
  205. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › What comes back from our six hypercomplex threads? [known]
    [known] They force a field zero, not an ordinary ζ zero at ½.
  206. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › What comes back from our six hypercomplex threads? [known]
    [known] Yes, through the scaled ζ factors and a no-cancellation check—not because quarters look special.
  207. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › What comes back from our six hypercomplex threads? [known]
    [known] It specifies a mirror, not a zero location. E₈ transfers through its product, while its centre stays empty.
  208. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › What comes back from our six hypercomplex threads? [known]
    [known] The intrinsic lift of ordinary ζ restricts exactly to ζ on each complex slice. “All its nontrivial zero spheres have real coordinate ½” is therefore equivalent to RH. Roundness and…
  209. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › And then, back to the actual number line [known]
    [known] If RH held for our larger Galois-field zeta, it would hold for ordinary ζ. That would imply prime-power counting error bounded by a constant times √x log²x, and prime-counting error…
  210. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Which return tickets actually carry weight? [known]
    [known] A zero-free region or zero-count upper bound for a larger Galois-field zeta descends to ordinary ζ. The converse does not follow. Known generic field bounds usually do not improve ζ’s…
  211. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Li positivity: finite and universal are different claims [known]
    [known] Completed-factor Li coefficients add. Finitely many positive field coefficients do not isolate the ordinary summand. But if every field Li coefficient is nonnegative, the Dedekind Li…
  212. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Which factor owns the zero? [known]
    [known] Stark’s simple-zero lemma is a precise ownership rule: a simple field-zeta zero belongs to exactly one degree-one Artin factor. If ordinary ζ also vanishes there, it is that factor; the…
  213. Zeros and primes › The zero waves belong to B, not A [known]
    [known] Substitute y=x 1/8 in the classical explicit formula above . Its main term becomes 8x 1/8 , and an inherited zero contributes −x ρ/8 /(ρ/8). For a checked pair ρ=½±iγ, the carrier size is…

Project (332)

Our own derivation, computation or experiment in these notes. Not a claim of novelty.

  1. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Today’s findings · a reading path [project, checked findings]
    [project, checked findings] 11 November. At 2, the four octonion orders differ; only G has local zeros on ½. Odd-prime factors have no zeros. Globally the inherited reference is 1/16—not a new RH…
  2. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Today’s findings · a reading path [project]
    [project] First separate the constructions. Turning the imaginary direction enlarges ordinary zeta’s zero picture. Counting ideals changes the function itself. A mirror pairs zeros; it need not…
  3. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 1 · Complex zeros become quaternion spheres [project]
    [project] Write a complex input as s=σ+it: σ is the horizontal real coordinate, and t is the vertical imaginary height. The critical line is σ=½. First we keep ordinary zeta and let its imaginary…
  4. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › More imaginary directions: the intrinsic construction [project]
    [project] This is an exact reduction, not an approximation. In particular, |ζ(x + rI)| = |ζ(x + ir)|. Turning the imaginary direction cannot change the size of the value or reveal a previously…
  5. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where ½ and the zeros go [project]
    [project] RH now says: every nontrivial zero sphere has its centre at ½ on the real axis. Off-line zeros would produce two mirror spheres, centred at a and 1 − a. The extra directions make the…
  6. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where ½ and the zeros go [project · checked]
    [project · checked] We sampled the first three zeta spheres in 12 directions each, in both algebras. The largest numerical zero residual was 4.22 × 10 −60 . Xi’s unwanted imaginary part on sampled…
  7. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny sign change changes which outputs are allowed [project · exact deduction]
    [project · exact deduction] With zeta’s plus-sign mirror, a fixed critical input has a real xi value. With the minus-sign mirror and real coefficients, a fixed critical input must instead have a…
  8. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny sign change changes which outputs are allowed [project]
    [project] A checked distinction in allowed outputs. The sign in the functional equation changes the target fixed set from real to purely imaginary. The drawings use explicit cosh/sinh models, not…
  9. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny sign change changes which outputs are allowed [project · checked models]
    [project · checked models] The simple models cosh(q − ½) and sinh(q − ½) show the contrast exactly. At q = ½ + rI, their outputs are cos r and I sin r. For r = .7, the first stays the real number…
  10. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny sign change changes which outputs are allowed [project, interval certificates]
    [project, interval certificates] For the three named Artin examples, the later height-100 work isolates 179, 180 and 224 positive zeros, matching independent Turing counts. The two negative-sign…
  11. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now checked: explicit fields, different answers [project · computed]
    [project · computed] We now have actual Artin L-values, not just a symmetry sketch. Two explicitly identified fields have the same eight-element quaternion group and the same conductor, 2304—a…
  12. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now checked: explicit fields, different answers [project]
    [project] 201 computed samples per curve, not a toy drawing. We remove a known rotating phase to make the values real, as with Hardy Z. Their absolute values are exactly |L(½ + it)|. The green…
  13. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now checked: explicit fields, different answers [project · checked]
    [project · checked] Separate 40-, 70- and 100-digit runs recover both signs without supplying them in advance. At 100 digits, PARI prints the negative example’s central value as 0.E-115 . That is…
  14. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now checked: explicit fields, different answers [project · exact arithmetic]
    [project · exact arithmetic] The negative example is the degree-eight field defined by x⁸ + 12x⁶ + 36x⁴ + 36x² + 9 = 0, LMFDB field 8.0.12230590464.1. The positive comparison uses x⁸ − 12x⁶ + 36x⁴…
  15. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now checked: explicit fields, different answers [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Full field, sign-certificate and L-value notebook · Interval certificate · Numerical results and plot samples · PARI checking script · Independent interval-sign script .
  16. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now checked: explicit fields, different answers [project · actual Artin values]
    [project · actual Artin values] We can now see that contrast without a toy. For the negative-sign example, Λ(½ + .1j) ≈ .6298337094j, while Λ(½ + .1k) ≈ .6298337094k. Those are different numbers…
  17. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The two central zeros are now proved simple [project · interval certified]
    [project · interval certified] Earlier, a nonzero numerical slope suggested that each forced central zero was a single crossing rather than a flatter, repeated zero. We have now enclosed the whole…
  18. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The two central zeros are now proved simple [project · proved for these examples]
    [project · proved for these examples] Neither interval touches zero. Together with the already certified mirror signs, that proves each central zero has multiplicity exactly one. The proof bounds…
  19. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The two central zeros are now proved simple [project · scope]
    [project · scope] This is an auditable computational proof for two explicit arithmetic functions, not a proof that every quaternionic Artin central zero is simple. The integral derivation and tail…
  20. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Change the arithmetic, keep the sign—with a condition [project · checked]
    [project · checked] We tested six such positive discriminants on each of our three bases: 18 twists. Every one kept its base sign. We checked exact initial coefficients, the new conductor N × D²,…
  21. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Change the arithmetic, keep the sign—with a condition [project · important control]
    [project · important control] The D=−4 comparison shares the ramified prime 2 and lies outside the coprime theorem, so its changed sign is no contradiction. The original table covers positive D…
  22. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Twist the arithmetic twelve times: the forced zero stays simple [project · interval proof]
    [project · interval proof] We enclosed the slope L′(½) of all twelve sign −1 twists (D = 13, 17, 29, 37, 53, 61 on both negative bases). Every slope lies between about 4.0 and 13.8, with error…
  23. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Twist the arithmetic twelve times: the forced zero stays simple [project · interval proof]
    [project · interval proof] Twelve positive-discriminant twists have derivative intervals avoiding zero, so their forced centres are simple. The table concerns these examples, not a universal…
  24. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Twist the arithmetic twelve times: the forced zero stays simple [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Method, table and caveats · Certificate script · All fourteen enclosures and error bounds
  25. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Real quaternion coefficients: the length is arithmetic, the direction is not [project · exact proof and checks]
    [project · exact proof and checks] So try the naive thing: multiply the quaternion factors (1 − g p p −s ) −1 in order, for real s > 1. Because the length of a product of quaternions is the…
  26. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Real quaternion coefficients: the length is arithmetic, the direction is not [project · floating point]
    [project · floating point] Primes below 20,000 at s = 3/2. The squared length matches across all 202 choices to about 10 −14 and matches PARI’s full L(ρ, 3/2) up to the omitted primes. Only real s…
  27. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Real quaternion coefficients: the length is arithmetic, the direction is not [project · interpretation]
    [project · interpretation] The extra directions are real, but they record our arbitrary choices, not arithmetic. This is a precise version of the earlier toy warning: noncommuting coefficients…
  28. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Real quaternion coefficients: the length is arithmetic, the direction is not [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Proof, numbers and limits · Checking script · All results
  29. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The section above used real s. For complex s = σ + ti, the factor p −s needs an imaginary unit, and there are two honest places to put it. If that i is one of the quaternion directions ,…
  30. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] If i is kept separate , commuting with the quaternions, each factor becomes a 2×2 complex matrix. Then the product’s determinant is exactly the Artin L-function for every choice and…
  31. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] Primes below 20,000, σ = 3/2, six sign choices per band. Exact closed form for each factor’s norm, plus 4,378 floating-point checks; the 2×2 determinant matches PARI’s L-function to…
  32. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] In plain words. Above, putting the complex unit inside the quaternions made the product keep only one factor for each prime that splits in one particular quadratic field, where Artin’s…
  33. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The identity. Write ρ for the 2-dimensional representation of Q8, F(s) for the aligned product, and χ u , χ v , χ w for the three quadratic characters (χ u belongs to the chosen unit). Then
  34. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] What follows. The fractional powers mean F can only be continued as a many-valued function. Going once around a zero of one of the L-functions multiplies F by a fixed factor: −1 for a…
  35. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] Left: the away-pointing primes’ product O(σ) sinks to 0 like a square root as σ → ½. The direct product converges too slowly to show this, so the curve uses the exact formula. Right:…
  36. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] Real part: the classical answer again. For each prime p we computed its Frobenius as an actual one of the 24 quaternions (up to p = 20 000, and for every prime of the field above p when…
  37. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] Only the real part is free of choices, for any such group. A simple argument shows more than we asked: for every non-commutative finite group of unit quaternions (Q8, 2T and the larger…
  38. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] Where the i, j, k part goes. Suppose you fix one quaternion for each type of prime once and for all. Then the left-over i, j, k part is a mixture of other L-functions. There is a natural…
  39. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] (a) Weights of the left-over i, j, k part on each L-function, for the aligned choice. (b) Near s = ½ the aligned product behaves like (s − ½) 3/8 , in both fields. (c) The factor from…
  40. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The aligned product, now with proved exponents. As for Q8, put the complex unit of s inside the quaternions, along the order-6 axis. The primes whose quaternion lies on that axis…
  41. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
    [project, proved] The aligned product, now with proved exponents. As for Q8, put the complex unit of s inside the quaternions, along the order-6 axis. The primes whose quaternion lies on that axis…
  42. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
    [project, proved] The aligned product, now with proved exponents. As for Q8, put the complex unit of s inside the quaternions, along the order-6 axis. The primes whose quaternion lies on that axis…
  43. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The line ½ is still a barrier, but a weaker one, and the power is now a theorem. The order-4 primes (a quarter of all primes) cannot lie on the chosen axis. Their axes meet it at…
  44. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The shrinking is never zero. The power β that appeared for the 24-element group is not special to that group. The same rule applies to every finite non-commutative group of unit…
  45. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [project, proved] For the dihedral family the minimum is exact. The binary dihedral groups Dic n (order 4n; Q₈ is the case n = 2) have a closed formula: the smallest β is ¼ when n is odd, and ½ −…
  46. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    the formula itself. [project, proved]
  47. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    (9 − √33)/24, the smaller root of 12β² − 9β + 1. [project, proved]
  48. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
    smallest root of 192β³ − 288β² + 126β − 13; certified global minimum. [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
  49. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
    smallest root of a degree-6 polynomial over Q (a cubic over ℚ(√5)); certified global minimum. [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
  50. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] A guess that failed. The 48-element minimum is 0.1487, which is larger than the 24-element minimum 0.1356. That disproves our earlier guess that a bigger group would always have a weaker…
  51. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
    [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic] Barrier exponent β as the axis I varies, for the three binary polyhedral groups. The red star is the minimiser. The values at those stars are…
  52. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] In plain words. A Frobenius quaternion has a real part and a pure (i, j, k) part. The real part is half the trace of ρ, so the zeros of L(ρ) hear it, including its forced zero at ½. The…
  53. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] A worked example, T = 1. Take the field 2.26569.24t7.b.a with a Gaussian-type test function of width T = 1. In the n-direction, the zeros of L(ρ⊗ω) above the axis add up…
  54. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] (b) The u-direction, share of each L-function. (c) The n-direction as the difference between zeros above and zeros below the real axis of L(ρ⊗ω). Field 2.26569.24t7.b.a;…
  55. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] How well it balances. For both fields (2.26569.24t7.b.a and .a.a) we compared the zero side with the archimedean terms plus the prime side, for 9 Gaussian widths T = 1…20…
  56. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The question. For the binary icosahedral group 2I (120 elements, the symmetries of the icosahedron lifted to unit quaternions) we repeat the check made for 2T: which L-functions “hear”…
  57. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Who carries what. The real part is exactly half of L(ρ), as before. The three pure directions, one for each kind of rotation axis of the icosahedron, are built only from the five…
  58. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] New data. From the functional equation (PARI, floating point): L(3), L(3′) and L(4) have conductor 2⁸·11²·23², the same as L(ρ); L(5) has 2⁸·11⁴·23⁴ ≈ 1.05·10¹². All have…
  59. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] Does it balance? With zeros of ζ, L(ρ), L(3), L(3′), L(4) up to height 70 (ζ: 110), the explicit formula balances for the real part and the 5-fold direction for Gaussian…
  60. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] 2I field, Model A. (a) residual per T; (b) share of each L-function at T = 1; (c) shifted windows; (d) which L-functions carry each layer. PARI zeros, uncertified.
  61. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] Two real Galois fields, computed in PARI. The LMFDB search for these representations is blocked from this host — the HTML pages by a captcha, and the API after the first slice of records…
  62. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] The 48-element field matches the predicted slope, to the accuracy of the cutoff, and has a simple forced zero. Along the best axis, with primes up to 20 000 (2 259…
  63. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
    [project, float numerics] The 48-element field matches the predicted slope, to the accuracy of the cutoff, and has a simple forced zero. Along the best axis, with primes up to 20 000 (2 259…
  64. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    The 120-element group 2I gives a different answer. [project, float numerics] On the same degree-120 field (ramified only at 2, 11 and 23), with Frobenius quaternions now known at all 33 860…
  65. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] The 120-element field matches too. With the same cutoff (2 242 unramified primes whose power-basis coefficients are integral; χ² = 10.86 on 8 degrees of freedom), the…
  66. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] (a) For the 48-element field, the completed Model A norm shrinks like (2σ − 1) 0.1509 in the last decade at height 11.3, against the predicted 0.1487. (b) One of its two…
  67. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved — computer-assisted]
    [project, proved — computer-assisted] An exact formula, along an 8-fold axis. For the same 48-element field as above, line the Frobenius quaternions up along one 8-fold axis (the analogue of the…
  68. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
    [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic] The exponent is 5/24, once one more L-value is granted. The morning certificate already gives a simple zero of L(ρ) at ½ and L(ρ⊗ε, ½) ≠ 0. The…
  69. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic]
    [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic] That 4-dimensional value is now certified not to vanish, and the root number is +1. σ 4 has conductor 2 959 360 000 and is entire unconditionally…
  70. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic + earlier slope check]
    [project, computer-assisted, interval arithmetic + earlier slope check] (a) Real exponents in the exact formula. Imaginary exponents are phases and do not change the size. (b) Near s = ½, log |F 8…
  71. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved — computer-assisted]
    [project, proved — computer-assisted] The same kind of formula, along a 10-fold axis. Take the 120-element field above (ramified only at 2, 11 and 23) and line the Frobenius quaternions up along…
  72. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, local root numbers + float numerics]
    [project, local root numbers + float numerics] The surprise: the 4-dimensional piece has to vanish. Both 2-dimensional L-functions have root number +1 here, so one would expect only the pole of…
  73. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, interval arithmetic, conditional]
    [project, interval arithmetic, conditional] The exponent is 1/24. L(ρ, ½) and L(ρ′, ½) now have interval enclosures: 5.851618798 ± 1.2·10 −10 and 0.5132584851 ± 8.8·10 −11 . The simple zero of…
  74. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, computer-assisted + float numerics]
    [project, computer-assisted + float numerics] (a) Real exponents in the exact formula. Imaginary exponents are phases and do not change the size. (b) Near s = ½, log |F 10 | has slope 1/24…
  75. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, interval arithmetic, conditional]
    [project, interval arithmetic, conditional] Each forced zero is simple. Here ρ′ is the √5 → −√5 partner of ρ, and it also has root number −1. All four derivatives at ½ were enclosed with interval…
  76. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, interval arithmetic + float numerics]
    [project, interval arithmetic + float numerics] The real function Z(t) on the critical line for ρ (solid) and ρ′ (dashed), with each curve scaled to its own maximum for |t| ≤ 3 (PARI floats).…
  77. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The question. Each aligned product above was written as a few Artin L-functions raised to fractional powers, times a leftover correction H. H is harmless at ½, but it only makes sense to…
  78. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The rule behind the edge. Write the logarithm of each prime’s factor as a sum over powers p −ks . The k = 1 and k = 2 layers are exactly what the L(χ, s) and L(χ, 2s) factors…
  79. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The bound. For every non-cyclic finite group of unit quaternions, on its standard axis, 1/6 ≤ ½ − σ ≤ 1/4. Both ends are attained, and the dihedral family contributes nothing…
  80. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Other axes. If the axis is chosen differently, the edge can move further left. Along a 4-fold axis of Dic p (p ≥ 5 prime) it is exactly 1/p. It approaches 0 as p grows but never…
  81. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] What this is not. The edge belongs to the correction factor H, so it says nothing about where zeros of ζ or of any L-function lie, and nothing about RH. The central exponents 3/8, 5/24…
  82. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved; checked by script]
    [project, proved; checked by script] Edge σ = 1/k₀ of the correction H for each group. Filled dots show the standard axis used on this page and hollow dots other axes. The shaded band is ¼ ≤ σ ≤…
  83. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The question. The 120-element field above had two 2-dimensional pieces ρ, ρ′ with root number +1, and its forced central zero sat on a 4-dimensional piece, Sym³ρ, giving exponent 1/24.…
  84. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved]
    [known] [project, proved] The root number of Sym³ρ is +1, by a local argument. At the one ramified prime p the local group is abelian, so ρ splits there as two characters ψ and ψ⁻¹, and Sym³ρ…
  85. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, floating-point numerics, conditional on Artin holomorphy]
    [project, floating-point numerics, conditional on Artin holomorphy] Its central value is not zero. Summing the functional-equation series with 35 million coefficients gives L(Sym³ρ, ½) =…
  86. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, conditional on Artin holomorphy for ρ, ρ′, Sym³ρ]
    [project, conditional on Artin holomorphy for ρ, ρ′, Sym³ρ] The exponent is 1/24 for both. The weights are the same as before: ρ counts 1/3, ρ′ counts −1/6, Sym³ρ counts 1/6, and ζ(2s) contributes…
  87. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] Not done. No interval certificate for L(Sym³ρ, ½) ≠ 0 (the kernel needs about 4·10⁷ terms); no value for the two remaining 3-dimensional pieces; no direct numerical check of the product…
  88. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The question. In the three binary-icosahedral fields above, the root numbers of ρ and of the 4-dimensional piece Sym³ρ multiply to −1 (+ and − for the first field, − and + for the other…
  89. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, floating-point numerics]
    [project, floating-point numerics] What was computed. For all eight records the functional equation of ρ holds to between 2⁻⁴⁹ and 2⁻⁵⁷ with the stated sign, and fails for the other one. For Sym³ρ…
  90. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proof sketch]
    [known] [project, proof sketch] Why the product is −1 here. The global root number is the product of local ones, and Tate’s rule ε(χ)ε(χ⁻¹) = χ(−1) handles each prime. At 701 the local group is…
  91. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The question. The exponent 1/24 above came with a proviso: three more L-functions of each field, L(3), L(3′) and L(4), must not vanish at s = ½. These are the pieces that cannot tell a…
  92. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, floating-point numerics, conditional on Artin holomorphy]
    [project, floating-point numerics, conditional on Artin holomorphy] None of the nine is zero. All have root number +1 and are positive. Each value was computed at least two ways: at 64 and at 160…
  93. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] What it settles. With these values the proviso is met in all three fields: the product F₁₀ behaves like c·(s − ½) 1/24 + 0.154 i with c ≠ 0, where the imaginary part comes from ζ(2s)…
  94. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] (a) The nine A₅ central values. (b) How closely the different methods agree.
  95. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The question. The subsections above say that in the fields 1951² and 2141² the 10-fold product behaves like F₁₀(s) ≈ c·(s − ½) 1/24 + 0.1539 i near s = ½, with c ≠ 0. That was read off…
  96. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, floating-point numerics, conditional on Artin holomorphy]
    [project, floating-point numerics, conditional on Artin holomorphy] How. Near ½ the Euler product of F₁₀ diverges, so F₁₀ can only be reached through its exact identity (a product of L-functions…
  97. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] What it shows. Both slopes come out as predicted (fits over the six smallest ε; the step-by-step slopes approach the predicted values in proportion to ε). The constant c is finite and…
  98. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] One subtlety. F₁₀ contains the factor ζ(s) 0.308 i , and ζ has a pole at s = 1, so F₁₀ has a branch point at s = 1. Its values between ½ and 1 depend on whether the continuation passes…
  99. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics]
    [project, float numerics] (a) log |F₁₀(½ + ε)| with the predicted lines log |c| + (1/24) log ε. (b) arg F₁₀(½ + ε) with arg c + 0.1539 log ε. (c) Gap between each step slope and the prediction.
  100. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] The aligned quaternion product F of the section above has no such mirror, so neither Hardy’s Z nor Levinson’s identity is available for it. What does carry over is Littlewood’s lemma: a…
  101. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project]
    [project] What we checked. We built each L(ρ, s) two ways in PARI: from the Galois group directly, and as the Hecke L-function of an order-4 character ψ of each of the three quadratic subfields.…
  102. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The output sphere can shrink and turn inside out [project · actual Artin measurements]
    [project · actual Artin measurements] For the negative conductor-2304 example, the output on a critical input sphere is B(t)I. At input radii .1, .7 and 1.2, B(t) is about .629834, 2.740344 and…
  103. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The output sphere can shrink and turn inside out [project]
    [project] Measured coefficients, schematic sphere outlines. We sampled 25 rational unit directions at each of four radii in all three fields. These use the exact slice formula, not independent…
  104. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The output sphere can shrink and turn inside out [project]
    [project] The positive comparison still sends each critical input sphere to one real point. At radius .7 it gives 21.746557725… in every direction. The difference is now visible in actual Artin…
  105. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The first reported positive Artin zero radii [project · numerical only]
    [project · numerical only] Two finer search meshes agree on the following low critical-line zeros. Each positive height becomes the radius of an entire quaternionic zero sphere centred at ½. These…
  106. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The first reported positive Artin zero radii [project]
    [project] Projected sphere outlines, with radii scaled from the numerical heights. The filled centres mark the two rigorously simple central point zeros. All three radii in every panel are now…
  107. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The first reported positive Artin zero radii [project · limit]
    [project · limit] Refinement at 70 decimal digits gives numerical L-residuals below 3.79 × 10 −75 . But two agreeing searches are not a Turing-complete zero count: they do not exclude missed…
  108. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The first reported positive Artin zero radii [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Full continuation, proofs and sources · Twist, zero and sphere-map data · Numerical checking script .
  109. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now proved: the first positive heights, and no missing zeros below 2 [project · interval proof]
    [project · interval proof] A tiny numerical residual is not enough. We have now proved opposite signs of the real Hardy-type function at the following exact decimal endpoints. Continuity puts a…
  110. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now proved: the first positive heights, and no missing zeros below 2 [project · independently counted]
    [project · independently counted] We also enclosed the function on an entire rectangle around the critical strip, not just at sample points. Its image winds around zero 3, 2 and 3 times…
  111. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now proved: the first positive heights, and no missing zeros below 2 [project · interval proof]
    [project · interval proof] Actual first-zero positions, with central zeros in gold. All 192 contour-segment image boxes avoid zero. The total count matches the certified on-line zeros. The three…
  112. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now proved: the first positive heights, and no missing zeros below 2 [project · assurance and scope]
    [project · assurance and scope] Arb, interval-arithmetic software running at 256 bits, supplies validated integrals for the signs; explicit estimates bound both infinite tails. The contour uses…
  113. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now proved: the first positive heights, and no missing zeros below 2 [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Proof, tail bounds and scope · Arb certificate script · All endpoint balls, contour boxes and winding records .
  114. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Beyond the first zeros: complete through height 50 [project · interval proof]
    [project · interval proof] A search along a line can miss a zero between samples—or off the line. We now do two separate jobs: trap every reported positive height between opposite, rigorous signs,…
  115. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Beyond the first zeros: complete through height 50 [project]
    [project] The signs come from a real-valued version of the completed L-function: keep Λ(½ + it) for sign +1, divide it by i for sign −1. Arb encloses this function using an explicit Bessel…
  116. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Beyond the first zeros: complete through height 50 [project · interval proof]
    [project · interval proof] The staircases use certified brackets. A separate argument-principle count proves completeness in each window; it is the same missing-zero task as a Turing check, not a…
  117. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Beyond the first zeros: complete through height 50 [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Full proof and explicit error bounds · 768-bit Arb certificate · Every bracket, contour box and winding receipt · Independent 5000-coefficient arithmetic audit .
  118. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The missing zero at the middle [project]
    [project] The half-line spacings are 4.532360141827 for D = 2 and 2.859600867380 for D = 3. We checked 48 selected nonreal zeros, with residuals below 8 × 10 −79 , plus limits from both sides of…
  119. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The whole real axis: a ladder of half-steps [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Derivation and caveats · Scan script · Roots, slopes and constants
  120. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The whole real axis: a ladder of half-steps [project, interval certificates]
    [project, interval certificates] The maximal-order maps are complete through height 10,000: 47,188, 48,478 and 55,806 positive nonreal zeros for D=2,3,30. The two outside families are transported…
  121. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 10,000: the complete three-line map [project]
    [project] The requested extension is now certified, not forecast. These are all positive-height nonreal zeros through 10,000, counted with multiplicity; the headings are real coordinates. The…
  122. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 10,000: the complete three-line map [project]
    [project] Every nonreal zero is simple. The centres remain nonzero for D = 2 and 3; D = 30 has its separate double centre. There are no extra nonreal roots or factor collisions in this window.
  123. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 10,000: the complete three-line map [project]
    [project] Fresh interval sign brackets locate 22,491 ordinary zeros through height 20,000 . A literal Trudgian/Turing integral bound on [20,000, 20,064] proves that none were missed. The exact…
  124. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 10,000: the complete three-line map [project]
    [project] Checkpoint reuse extended the same source-pinned pipeline rather than starting over. Numerical generation plus full replay took 8.2 minutes, with 51.7 MiB peak memory; this excludes…
  125. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 10,000: the complete three-line map [project]
    [project] The same known growth contrast at a larger scale: each inherited line grows like T log T, while the middle local family grows linearly. Solid curves join certified count samples; dashed…
  126. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 10,000: the complete three-line map [project]
    [project] The mobile map isolates D = 30. Each cell counts 100 height units; it is not an individual root dot or a precise location plot.
  127. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Inheritance, not interaction [project]
    [project] How close do an inherited height and a local height get? We checked the entire positive window through 10,000. The table gives certified lower bounds for the minimum vertical gap; the…
  128. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Inheritance, not interaction [project]
    [project] The calculation bounds every nearest local lattice point with intervals, not rounded root lists. A separate 288-bit replay agrees. Matching upper bounds and the root indices are in the…
  129. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Inheritance, not interaction [project]
    [project] A close height is not a shared zero: the roots lie on different vertical lines. The diagram exaggerates their vertical difference. Both outer lines give the same comparison.
  130. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Inheritance, not interaction [project]
    [known] The horizontal separation is still ¼, even if two heights were exactly equal. The factorization superposes zero families; these nearby heights do not establish attraction, repulsion or any…
  131. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [project]
    [project] The three families persist. These are all positive-height nonreal zeros, not selected dots. The column headings are real coordinates; the centre is excluded from the totals.
  132. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [project]
    [project] Every nonreal zero in these windows is simple . The D = 2 and 3 centres remain nonzero; D = 30 still has a separate double central zero. At height 1,000 its middle-line count is 220 +…
  133. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [project]
    [project] We applied Trudgian’s literal integral bound—not a library count relabelled as Turing. For the low window we certified 341 ordinary zeros through 600, then selected the 79 below 200; the…
  134. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [project]
    [project] The order-zeta completeness proof is the exact transport identity plus that ordinary-zeta certificate , not a giant new order-zeta contour. All complementary factors were also…
  135. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [project]
    [project] One growth comparison: each outer line grows like T log T, while the local middle line grows linearly. Dashed curves are the familiar main terms, not independent predictions. Certified…
  136. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [project]
    [project] This updated map uses ten-height count cells, not thousands of overlapping root dots. On mobile D = 30 is isolated. The counts are exact; colour intensity is only a visual guide.
  137. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Height 100 and 1,000: now complete, with a literal Turing bound [project]
    [project] The height-1,000 run originally queued 10,000 as its follow-up. That extension is now certified above . Its original 15–30 minute timing estimate was only a forecast; actual measured…
  138. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Original complete height-30 map, retained for comparison [project]
    [project] We finished the finite off-axis check. “Height” is the imaginary coordinate. For the maximal quaternion-order zetas with D = 2, 3 and 30, every nonreal zero through height 30 is now…
  139. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Original complete height-30 map, retained for comparison [project]
    [project] Each has 13 simple zeros on each inherited line , at real coordinates ¼ and ¾. The middle line, real coordinate ½, has 6, 10 and 31 nonreal zeros respectively, all simple. The 31 for D =…
  140. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Original complete height-30 map, retained for comparison [project]
    [project] All nonreal zeros through height 30, not selected roots. Markers are far larger than the certified brackets. The mobile view isolates D = 30; the table keeps all three totals. Full…
  141. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The original height-30 completeness check [project]
    [project] First we counted every ordinary-zeta zero through height 60, then transported them by the known exact formula. Thirteen critical-line sign brackets and their negative-height partners…
  142. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The original height-30 completeness check [project]
    [project] Every whole contour piece , not just its endpoints, was enclosed with interval arithmetic. A 512-bit replay validated 40,702 pieces, including extra subdivisions wherever a coarser image…
  143. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › What this does not say about RH [project]
    [project] Unlike the independent subfield computation , this run openly uses ordinary ζ and its known factorization. It is a complete finite check of the map, not a new arithmetic L-function, an…
  144. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Nonmaximal quaternion orders: the Eichler comparison [project · our own names]
    [project · our own names] Two kinds of zero. Grant’s names, used only on this site. They are not standard terminology.
  145. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Nonmaximal quaternion orders: the Eichler comparison [project, proved in these notes]
    [project, proved in these notes] For the split local Eichler family, both the invertible-ideal and all-module correction polynomials have all their roots on the circle corresponding to Re s=½. The…
  146. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 1 · How many invertible ideals there are [project · proved]
    [project · proved] [original proof] For every prime p and level r, the number a e of invertible right ideals of reduced norm p e is (e+1)p e when e < r, and [((r+1)p − (r−1))p e − (p+1)p r−1…
  147. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 · Every one of those zeros is on the half-line [project · proved]
    [project · proved] [original proof] Every root of Q r inv has |u| = 1/p. Since |u| = p −2·Re s , that is exactly Re s = ½: all of these local zeros sit on the half-line. The idea of the proof is a…
  148. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 · Every one of those zeros is on the half-line [project]
    [project] The invertible local factor’s roots all land on the circle |u| = 1/p, which is the half-line Re s = ½.
  149. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Counting all modules, not just invertible ones [project · proved, refereed]
    [project · proved, refereed] The larger “Solomon” count includes all finite-index right submodules of the regular order (right ideals), not just invertible ones. Its correction has degree 2r in v…
  150. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Counting all modules, not just invertible ones [project · proved, refereed]
    [project · proved, refereed] The remaining coefficients and the mirror symmetry follow from the column-pair formula above. [open] A short search found this formula nowhere in the literature; that…
  151. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 4 · Those zeros are on the half-line too [project · proved, refereed]
    [project · proved, refereed] [original proof] Every root of the Solomon factor has |v| = p −1/2 , which again means Re s = ½. The proof is the same sign-counting idea with a more elaborate curve:…
  152. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 4 · Those zeros are on the half-line too [project]
    [project] The sign lemma in pictures: the curve alternates at the marked test angles, so a root is trapped between each neighbouring pair.
  153. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 4 · Octonion orders: the prime 2 changes the count [project · proved, double-computed]
    [known] For Coxeter’s integral octonions (the E 8 lattice), every one-sided ideal is two-sided and of the form mO (Petersson, Integral octonions , 2018 notes, Thm. 1; van der Blij–Springer 1959;…
  154. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 4 · Octonion orders: the prime 2 changes the count [project · proved, computer-assisted, double-computed]
    [project · proved, computer-assisted, double-computed] For the integer-coordinate (Gravesian) octonions Z 8 , the count at the prime 2 is Q(x)/(1−x 4 ) with x = 2 −s and Q = 1+x+7x 2 +7x 3 +14x 4…
  155. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 4 · Octonion orders: the prime 2 changes the count [project · proved, computer-assisted]
    [project · proved, computer-assisted] R has full 2-local factor (1+3x²)/(1−x⁴), x=2^(−s). Its numerator has two zeros on Re s=log 3/log 4≈0.7925 and a mirror there. The full local factor has no…
  156. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Every order between Z 8 and E 8 [project · computed exactly]
    [project · computed exactly] There are exactly 16 orders containing Z 8 : Z 8 itself, a single order S 1 of index 2 (add ω = (1+e 1 +…+e 7 )/2), seven orders of index 4 (the order R above and six…
  157. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Every order between Z 8 and E 8 [project · proved, computer-assisted, double-computed]
    [project · proved, computer-assisted, double-computed] For S 1 the count at 2 is (1+2x+15x 2 +35x 3 +14x 4 +14x 5 )/(1−x 4 ), with x = 2 −s . Two separate programs (different algorithms, one…
  158. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Every order between Z 8 and E 8 [project]
    [project] One prime-2 period for G, S₁ and R. Only G has numerator zeros on the dashed half-line. E₈’s local numerator is 1, so it has none.
  159. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Every order between Z 8 and E 8 [project · proved, computer-assisted, independently re-computed]
    [project · proved, computer-assisted, independently re-computed] Re-count of all 16 orders (11 November). The morning result checked one order of each kind. A third program, written from scratch…
  160. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 is exceptional: what happens at 3, 5 and 7? [project, computer-assisted]
    [known] [project, computer-assisted] At odd primes the local numerator is 1: the empty panels are the answer. Prime-2 dots are earlier project results. Heights use Im(s)log(p)/(2π), normalized…
  161. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 is exceptional: what happens at 3, 5 and 7? [project, computer-assisted]
    [project, computer-assisted] Checked two ways. A new Fano-table calculation finds 64 products of right-multiplication matrices and verifies explicit formulas for every elementary matrix, using…
  162. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project]
    [project] The odd primes above gave nothing because every order there was maximal: only scaled copies were ideals. So we now make the order imperfect at 3 on purpose. Near 3 the octonions are the…
  163. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, double-computed]
    [project, double-computed] None of the six orders has a zero on Re s = ½. This is an exact test, not a numerical impression. A zero on the line would be a common root of N(x) and its reflection x…
  164. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project]
    [project] Zeros of the local ideal-counting factor, one vertical period each (height Im s × log p / 2π). Dashed gold: Re s = ½. Top: prime 2, earlier orders. Below: prime 3, the new odd-conductor…
  165. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Be careful with Z₃ + 3O: its ideal theory is degenerate. Every lattice squeezed between 9O and 3O counts as an ideal, so the coefficients are subspace counts, as large as…
  166. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved from the local counts]
    [project, proved from the local counts] Globally nothing changes at the other primes, so the whole count is ζ(8s) × (1 − 3 −8s ) × Z Λ,3 (s). Its zeros are the inherited zeta zeros, rescaled to Re…
  167. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, exact test]
    [project, exact test] We built the same damaged orders at p = 5 and p = 7, and two of them also at p = 11, and counted their ideals again with two independent programs. At every prime, no zero of…
  168. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project conjecture]
    [project conjecture] The counts look like polynomials in p. Each coefficient of the local polynomial is a fixed polynomial in p, and its base-p digits are the same at 5 and 7. For N4 and P5 we…
  169. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project]
    [project] Zeros of the p-local ideal-counting factor for p = 3 (circles), 5 (squares) and 7 (triangles), one vertical period each. Dashed gold: Re s = ½. The pattern barely moves with p, and no…
  170. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, exact from the local polynomials]
    [project, exact from the local polynomials] The explicit formula keeps its odd-prime signal. There are new signed jumps at p, p², …. For P6 they are 2(p+1), −2(p+1)² + 4, 2(p+1)³, … at p², p⁴, p⁶.…
  171. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Instead of computing one prime at a time, we can now prove two of the patterns for every odd prime p. The idea is simple. Near p an octonion is a 2×2 array [[a, u], [v, b]].…
  172. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Neither ever has a zero on Re s = ½. For P6 every zero sits at Re s = log(p+1)/(2 log p), which is always a little more than ½, because p + 1 > p. For Q an exact algebraic test…
  173. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project]
    [project] The zeros nearest ½, as functions of p. Solid: proved for every p (P6, Q, N4, U). As p grows they crowd toward ½ (N4’s pairs within 1/(4√2 p 1.5 log p), now derived), yet none is ever on…
  174. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] N4 and P5 are now proved too. Their multiplication only pushes coordinates along chains, so the trick above (copying a pair across and back) is not available. A different idea…
  175. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] So neither ever has a zero on Re s = ½ , for any odd prime: the same exact resultant test now needs no “if”. For N4 we can also derive , not just measure, how tightly its zeros…
  176. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Left: the 256 cells of the N4 proof, grouped by their proved count. Right: N4’s zeros nearest ½, rescaled by p 1.5 log p, settle on the derived limits ±1/(4√2) ≈ ±0.177 (dashed).…
  177. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] U is proved too, so all five patterns now hold for every odd prime. 750 of U’s 802 box pairs are counted the same way as N4 and P5. In the other 52, hull and core are two steps…
  178. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] How the last 52 were counted. We first counted the same cells in a look-alike world where p · p = 0 but the digits never carry (polynomials in a symbol t with t² = 0). There the…
  179. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Odd conductor: damage the order at 3, and zeros appear, just not on ½ [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Left: U’s 802 cells by their proved count; gold marks the 52 two-step cells counted in this step. Right: those 52 cells, formula against exhaustive search at p = 3, 5, 7; all 156…
  180. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The whole count is ordinary zeta, rescaled, with a finite correction at 2. At every odd prime the orders agree. Multiplying those factors by the right factor at 2 gives the four…
  181. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Multiply before drawing the poles. The odd-prime product is ζ(8s)(1−x 8 ). For G, S 1 and R, that last factor cancels the local denominator 1−x 4 , leaving 1+x 4 . For E 8 it…
  182. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [project, computer-assisted]
    [known / project, proved] [project, computer-assisted] The same axes compare the four global counts. Green: 102 certified inherited zeros divided by eight. Rust: local numerator zeros, with…
  183. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The same completion fails for G, S 1 and R. Write the finite correction in the table as D(x). Their usual completions are ξ(8s)D(2 −s ). Each has a zero at s = iπ/(4 log 2), but…
  184. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [project, proved]
    [project, proved] G’s local numerator still has its mirror about ½. But the inherited zeta center is 1/16 and the new column from 1+x 4 is centered at 0: these do not make one global mirror. R’s…
  185. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] G has a local numerator mirror at ½, but that does not force all its zeros onto ½. Four sit on the mirror; four sit off in reflected pairs. R’s numerator has a different mirror,…
  186. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved / numerical coordinates]
    [project, proved / numerical coordinates] One period of G’s local numerator zeros. Arrows pair the four rust off-line roots; rings mark the four gold fixed roots. Reflection is not a force pulling…
  187. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Gold marks a numerator’s mirror; green marks the inherited 1/16 reference. Rust arrows pair genuine roots. Red crosses mark missing reflected partners—not zeros. Local…
  188. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Put u = x + 1/(2x). Then the exact identity is
  189. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] On |x| = 1/√2, u is real and lies between −√2 and √2. A rational Sturm calculation proves P has exactly two real roots: one between −5/4 and −1, the other between 0 and 1. Each…
  190. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] A meromorphic “gamma-like” equation is easy to write. Set r(s) = 1/8−s and H(s) = ξ(8s)D(2 −s ). Then
  191. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The ratio has the zeros and poles needed to compensate for the missing mirror partners. It is an exact meromorphic identity, not a nonvanishing conductor factor or a new…
  192. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The normalized reciprocal polynomial partner fails an arithmetic test. Write D(x) = Σa k x k of degree d, and A = 2 −1/8 . The formal dual D ∨ (x) = x d D(A/x)/(a d A d ) has…
  193. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] Numbers of ideals must be whole numbers. ζ(8s) cannot repair these first coefficients, since its first nonconstant term has index 256. Thus this reciprocal partner is not an…
  194. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [project, proved]
    [project, proved] The normalizer for G and S 1 now has a conceptual proof, not just a computer check. Let T i mean right multiplication by an imaginary basis unit. Linearized alternativity gives T…
  195. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Why are octonion orders strange at 2? [project, computer-assisted]
    [project, computer-assisted] All four reductions have 256 elements, but they are not the same algebra. G/2G becomes commutative and associative ; O/2O remains a noncommutative, nonassociative…
  196. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Why are octonion orders strange at 2? [project, computer-assisted]
    [project, computer-assisted] Gold cells show the nilpotent ideal N; green cells its quotient; rust bars the associator span. Dot strips count zeros, not their positions. Integral inclusions do not…
  197. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Why are octonion orders strange at 2? [project, proved]
    Why the collapse happens. For G the norm is q(x)=x 0 2 +⋯+x 7 2 , with polar matrix 2I. Its polar form vanishes modulo 2, as do its commutators and associators. In fact [project, proved] G/2G ≅ F…
  198. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Part II · Where the extra directions make a difference [project]
    [project] The reduction above describes one very natural extension of zeta. It does not say that all quaternionic or octonionic mathematics is the same as complex analysis. Here are several places…
  199. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A sphere really can turn into one point [project]
    [project] To break zeta’s directional symmetry, we tried a Dirichlet L-function: a relative of zeta whose terms have repeating weights. Modulo 5, choose weights 1, J, −J, −1, 0, repeating with the…
  200. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A sphere really can turn into one point [project · checked]
    [project · checked] A numerical zero occurs at ½ + 6.18357819545…J. Its residual is 1.70 × 10 −65 . Keep the same real part and imaginary size, but turn away from J. Perpendicular to J, the…
  201. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A sphere really can turn into one point [project]
    [project] Computed example and exact angular law: the norm equals 2.81727798… times sin(θ/2), where θ is the angle from J. This is a zero on the generalized critical line, not a counterexample to…
  202. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Turn from i toward j and k [project · checked]
    [project · checked] The directional difference is not limited to one example. A second mod-5 zero has height 8.45722917442…. For an order-three mod-7 character, two checked heights are…
  203. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Turn from i toward j and k [project]
    [project] Fix the character’s direction as i. The norm depends only on the angle away from i: its constant-norm curves are latitude circles, not usually great circles. But turning around that…
  204. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Turn from i toward j and k [project]
    [project] Interactive exact angular profile evaluated with rounded coefficients from the first mod-5 zero. Move the second slider while keeping the first fixed: components change, norm stays…
  205. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › When a familiar formula changes—or stops being a single answer [project · checked]
    [project · checked] Give prime 2 coefficient i and prime 3 coefficient j. At the ordinary real input s = 2, the Euler factors (1 − i/4) −1 and (1 − j/9) −1 do not commute. Reversing them flips the…
  206. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › When a familiar formula changes—or stops being a single answer [project · checked]
    [project · checked] Both logarithms exponentiate to −1, yet they give different values for the proposed power (−1) j . Without a logarithm branch, that expression is not one uniquely specified…
  207. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Square it: a sphere becomes a number [project]
    [project] Subtract ½ and square. For any imaginary direction I, (rI)² = −r². A whole critical sphere folds to a single negative real number. Conversely, only points on that critical hyperplane can…
  208. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Square it: a sphere becomes a number [project]
    [project] Schematic sphere-to-point fold. The first zeta sphere has radius 14.13472514… and folds to −199.79045483…. The next two fold to −441.92615057… and −625.54299689….
  209. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Square it: a sphere becomes a number [project · checked]
    [project · checked] Three small coefficient-matrix determinants, at sizes 2, 3 and 4, were 2.2984 × 10 −8 , 1.1969 × 10 −12 and 4.2326 × 10 −17 . Positive—but finite spot checks cannot establish…
  210. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The finite sphere: ordinary linking [project]
    [project] The catch is on the output side. Nonzero quaternions retract to a 3-sphere, and nonzero octonions to a 7-sphere. Every loop in either of those shrinks away. A value-loop alone therefore…
  211. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The finite sphere: ordinary linking [project · proved and checked]
    [project · proved and checked] The factor 2 comes from two oppositely directed preimages whose orientation signs agree. A direct test with q² + 1 gives two positive preimages of a regular target…
  212. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The finite sphere: ordinary linking [project · correction]
    [project · correction] Degree counts multiplicity; raw sign changes do not. An even-multiplicity zero does not change a real function’s sign. So RH is not equivalent to “degree equals twice the…
  213. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Watch two spheres collide and leave the critical plane [project]
    [project] Here is a fully solved toy, not zeta: P a (q) = [ (q − ½)² + 1 ]² − a. For positive a near zero, it has two critical spheres of different radii. At a = 0 they merge into one double…
  214. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Watch two spheres collide and leave the critical plane [project]
    [project] Exact roots, schematic projection. For a > 0 the radii are √(1 ± √a). For a < 0 the squared coordinates are −1 ± i√(−a). The button starts motion; the slider works without animation.…
  215. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Watch two spheres collide and leave the critical plane [project · checked]
    [project · checked] In our earlier two-frequency heat toy, the exact threshold is log(4)/3 = 0.46209812037…. Just below it, one pair is π ± 0.04475865i; just above it, the pair is π ± 0.04468412.…
  216. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Watch two spheres collide and leave the critical plane [project · important limit]
    [project · important limit] This heat flow acts within complex slices. It is not ordinary diffusion across four or eight real coordinates. For example, the ambient Laplacian of q² is −4 in…
  217. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › What happens to the rest of the toolkit? [project]
    [project] Its determinant is |h′|²(B/r) d−2 for h(x+ir)=A+iB. For xi, B vanishes across the whole critical hyperplane—even where xi is nonzero. A vanishing determinant is therefore not a zero locator.
  218. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › What happens to the rest of the toolkit? [project · checked]
    [project · checked] As a separate arithmetic sanity check, a 2000-term Möbius inverse sum at 3 + 2.1i lies inside its explicit tail bound of 1.25 × 10 −7 . It is the same check in every direction…
  219. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The horned-sphere question was not finished [project]
    [project] A finite zero sphere is round, not horned. But there are infinitely many. Bring infinity into the picture as one extra point, the way a plane becomes a sphere by adding its point at…
  220. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The horned-sphere question was not finished [project]
    [project] An infinity phenomenon, not a drawing of an Alexander horned sphere. The compactified set is not itself a sphere or a connected surface. Under inversion, the radii of computed zero…
  221. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The horned-sphere question was not finished [project]
    [project] There is a precise finite count too. The complement of n distinct zero spheres in this rotational configuration has fundamental group F n : the free group on n loop generators. “Free”…
  222. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The horned-sphere question was not finished [project]
    [project] Away from the real axis, write a point as its real coordinate, its positive imaginary radius and its imaginary direction. The complement becomes a punctured upper half-plane times S² or…
  223. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The horned-sphere question was not finished [project]
    [project] Another small but real feature: each zero sphere links the compactified real axis once. Its spanning disk crosses the real axis once. Equivalently, remove the axis and that sphere cannot…
  224. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A precise answer about the loops at infinity [project · proved for this arrangement]
    [project · proved for this arrangement] Move the boundary farther out. The inner holes disappear from view, but there are always more beyond them. Each farther region has a free loop group…
  225. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A precise answer about the loops at infinity [project]
    [project] Each dot represents a whole zero sphere in the two-coordinate orbit picture. The diagrams are schematic, not actual zero gaps. The infinity-end calculation is an analytic topological…
  226. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A precise answer about the loops at infinity [project]
    [project] The sequence of groups and inclusion maps is an inverse system . Every loop word uses only finitely many named holes, so no one nonempty finite word belongs to every tail: the ordinary…
  227. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where octonions actually behave differently [project]
    [project] That is genuinely octonionic behavior. But both points have real part 0 and imaginary size 1. The angle changes; the sphere carrying the zero does not. Even this effect does not force a…
  228. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A three-direction toy: the parentheses move the zero [project · exact constructed toy]
    [project · exact constructed toy] Take three finite Euler-like factors A = 1 − we₁, B = 1 − we₂ and C = 1 − we₄. “Euler-like” describes their shape only: these are not prime coefficients or an…
  229. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A three-direction toy: the parentheses move the zero [project · exact]
    [project · exact] Both have exactly one isolated zero on the same imaginary-unit sphere. Their normal polynomials are both (1 + w²)³. The direction changes, not the real part or radius. Replacing…
  230. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A three-direction toy: the parentheses move the zero [project]
    [project] The 431 exact rational checks and recorded results include norm multiplicativity, alternativity, the published example, the associative control and both new roots. This tests a real…
  231. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › E₈: a real lattice difference, and a different mirror centre [project]
    [project] These are computed projections of actual lattice vectors, not decorative point clouds. Many vectors overlap in the shadow. The counts independently agree with the classical E₄…
  232. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny ways things differ: a map [project]
    [project] Holes at infinity
  233. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Do zeros move? Movement, phase and duality [project]
    [project] For the discriminant-30 order, no inherited height equals a local height through height 10,000; the closest certified miss there is about 0.0000092. Turning the dial’s angle instead of…
  234. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Do zeros move? Movement, phase and duality [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Invertible count proof · Unit-circle proof · Solomon closed form and Q₁–Q₄ · Solomon sign lemma · Referee pass · All-level Solomon proof · Chebyshev circle proof · Night…
  235. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [project]
    [project] The distinction to keep: rotating a real-coefficient zeta changes its geometric picture, while counting ideals changes the arithmetic function. A change of exponent rescales zero…
  236. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [project · reproducible]
    [project · reproducible] Earlier height-50 certificates and maximal quaternion-order formulas Quaternion Euler products from actual Frobenius elements All twelve twisted central zeros proved…
  237. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 5 · What these comparisons mean [project]
    [project] Today’s return-map audit: ranked transfer bridges and the all-index Li qualification ; which Artin factor owns a zero, and what the bookkeeping cannot exclude ; and an independent…
  238. How much of the critical line can we prove? [project]
    [known] How to read the labels. Every claim carries one tag. [known] is published mathematics, with the source named (full list in the sources ). [project] is something we computed or checked…
  239. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 2. Hardy's Z(t): a zero on the line is a sign change [project]
    Z(t) for 0 < t < 60 [project] . It changes sign 13 times, at the 13 zeros of ζ below height 60 (14.1347, 21.0220, 25.0109, 30.4249, 32.9351, 37.5862, 40.9187, 43.3271, 48.0052, 49.7738, 52.9703,…
  240. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 2. Hardy's Z(t): a zero on the line is a sign change [project]
    Z(t) for 0 < t < 60 [project] . It changes sign 13 times, at the 13 zeros of ζ below height 60 (14.1347, 21.0220, 25.0109, 30.4249, 32.9351, 37.5862, 40.9187, 43.3271, 48.0052, 49.7738, 52.9703,…
  241. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 2. Hardy's Z(t): a zero on the line is a sign change [project]
    Z(t) for 0 < t < 60 [project] . It changes sign 13 times, at the 13 zeros of ζ below height 60 (14.1347, 21.0220, 25.0109, 30.4249, 32.9351, 37.5862, 40.9187, 43.3271, 48.0052, 49.7738, 52.9703,…
  242. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 2. Hardy's Z(t): a zero on the line is a sign change [project]
    Z(t) for 0 < t < 60 [project] . It changes sign 13 times, at the 13 zeros of ζ below height 60 (14.1347, 21.0220, 25.0109, 30.4249, 32.9351, 37.5862, 40.9187, 43.3271, 48.0052, 49.7738, 52.9703,…
  243. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 3. Hardy–Littlewood (1921): sign changes in windows, and why that gives only ≫ T [project]
    What short windows actually contain [project] compute/hl_windows.json , Z from our own Riemann–Siegel program, 40/40 windows re-checked with mpmath . Windows [t, t + c/log t] tiling 1000 ≤ t ≤ 2000:
  244. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 3. Hardy–Littlewood (1921): sign changes in windows, and why that gives only ≫ T [project]
    For short windows the fraction equals λ almost exactly: a window essentially never holds two zeros, because zeros repel each other (independent random points would give the last column, noticeably…
  245. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [project]
    A toy mollifier, by numbers [project] compute/toy_mollifier.py → compute/toy_mollifier.json . Take Levinson's taper P(x) = x and mollifiers of length y = 1 (no mollifier), 5, 10, 20, 32 (≈ T 1/2 )…
  246. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [project]
    Reading it [project] :
  247. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [project]
    [project] compute/fig_toy_mollifier.py . |ζ(½ + it)| (blue) and
  248. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 4. The mollifier: what it is and why it is needed [project]
    [project] Curves are on 1000 ≤ t ≤ 1030 at 1,201 points (step 0.025) from our own Euler–Maclaurin ζ in numpy, with Levinson’s taper P(x) = x; |ζ·M| was checked against mpmath at 61 points (largest…
  249. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [project]
    unsigned window integrals: ∫ (∫ t t+h |F(u)| du)² dt = O(h² T 1/2 log T / log X) (Lemma 10.19). Dividing, signed/unsigned = (h/log X)/(h² log T/log X) = 1/(h log T) = ac : in mean square the…
  250. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 5. Selberg (1942): mollified sign changes in short windows [project]
    The good set has positive density. Let E be the set of t in (0, T) where ∫ t t+h |F| > |∫ t t+h F| — on E the function F changes sign inside (t, t + h). Off E the two integrals agree, so all the…
  251. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [project]
    [project] identity re-derived by hand — the ξ′ terms cancel because ξ′(1 − s) = −ξ′(s). On the line, 1 − s is the complex conjugate of s and everything has real coefficients, so the right side is…
  252. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [project]
    or in Conrey's words: "if the proportion of zeros of [G] to the right of the critical line is ≤ p, then the proportion of zeros of ζ on the critical line is ≥ 1 − 2p" [known] Conrey 1989 §1 . The…
  253. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [project]
    This is where the mollifier is indispensable: without it the mean square of |G| grows like log T and the bound becomes useless; with M ≈ 1/G it tends to a constant c, and the closer c is to 1 the…
  254. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [project]
    Worked illustration — the whole argument at small heights [project] compute/levinson_*.json; all double-computed; none of this is asymptotic or a theorem .
  255. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [project]
    [project] G = ζ + ζ′/L with L = log(100/2π) = 2.767; 4,501 points on 10 ≤ t ≤ 100 (step 0.02), computed twice (mpmath and our own numpy program). The 29 crossings sit on the 29 zeros of ζ there…
  256. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [project]
    The last two rows are the case for the mollifier in one line: even at height 300 the spikes of |G| inflate the mean square so much that the concavity step throws away everything [project]…
  257. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 6. Levinson (1974): count the zeros that are not on the line [project]
    The last two rows are the case for the mollifier in one line: even at height 300 the spikes of |G| inflate the mean square so much that the concavity step throws away everything [project]…
  258. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [project]
    Intuition. The mollifier M has length y = T θ . The longer it is, the better it imitates 1/G, the flatter |G·M| is, the smaller the mean square c, and the bigger κ = 1 − (log c)/R. In Young's…
  259. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [project]
    Why θ is capped. In the expanded mean square, an off-diagonal term oscillates like (hm/kn) it . With h, k ≤ T θ and m, n ≲ T, two different integers hm ≠ kn are far enough apart that integrating…
  260. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [project]
    Our evaluation of Young's formula [project] compute/levinson_kappa.json and levinson_extrap.json ; two independent integrators (Gauss–Legendre in numpy, mpmath.quad) agree to about 10⁻¹⁴ :
  261. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [project]
    The ratio 0.34744/0.34274 ≈ 1.014 matches the "only 1.4%" improvement in Levinson's 1975 PNAS abstract [project] consistent with sources . Conrey's 0.4077/0.4088 at θ = 4/7 is higher than our…
  262. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [project]
    Past 4/7 — formula only, no theorem [project] . Evaluating the same formula at θ = 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0 gives 0.419, 0.471, 0.516, 0.554, 0.5866 . These are not theorems: for ζ itself no mean…
  263. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 7. Longer mollifier ⇒ bigger share: the role of θ, and why 4/7 matters [project]
    Past 4/7 — formula only, no theorem [project] . Evaluating the same formula at θ = 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0 gives 0.419, 0.471, 0.516, 0.554, 0.5866 . These are not theorems: for ζ itself no mean…
  264. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 9. Worked example: Z(t) sign changes versus N(T) up to height 2000 [project]
    [project] double-computed: A = mpmath (siegelz on a 0.02 grid, grampoint, nzeros), B = our own Riemann–Siegel program in numpy (main sum + first correction term, own θ, own Gram points, 0.005…
  265. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 9. Worked example: Z(t) sign changes versus N(T) up to height 2000 [project]
    Sampling Z only at Gram points catches fewer: 1358/1517 ≈ 89.5% up to 2000, and the miss rate grows with T (Gram's law fails more and more often). How you look decides how many zeros you can…
  266. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 9. Worked example: Z(t) sign changes versus N(T) up to height 2000 [project]
    1 + θ(T)/π (the smooth part of N(T)) is within 0.6 of N(T) at every checkpoint, e.g. 1516.99 vs 1517 [project] .
  267. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    This section is about the project's own objects (see /workspace/math/lit/quaternionic-zeta/hyper-critical/, especially q8-half-hecke-20261111.md). Labels matter more than usual here. No [project]…
  268. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    10.1 The classical Q8 Artin L-function L(ρ, s). Here K/ℚ is Galois with group Q8 and ρ is its 2-dimensional faithful representation; L(ρ, s) equals a Hecke L-function L(F, ψ, s) of a quadratic…
  269. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    Check [project] compute/q8_hardy_z.py → q8_hardy_z.json ; PARI only, so a consistency check rather than an independent double computation : for 2.2304.8t5.b.a (W = −1) and 2.2304.8t5.a.a (W = +1),…
  270. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    Does that cover our L(ρ, s)? Yes. Update 12 November 2026: the standard step is now cited and checked ( Q₈ Artin L-function as a Maass newform ). The original reasoning follows. Here ρ is even…
  271. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    Levinson's Steps A–D are pure algebra and complex analysis for any L-function with this kind of functional equation [project] elementary: the Step A algebra used only ξ(s) = ξ(1 − s) and real…
  272. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    10.2 The aligned quaternion "half-L-function" F. The project's Model A product over split primes is ( q8-half-hecke note , result 1, [project] exact )
  273. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    No Z-function, no mirror identity [project] elementary . The representation above gives F no reflection law about ½: the factor [ζ(2s)/L(χ u , 2s)] 1/4 reflects about s = ¼ (2s ↔ 1 − 2s), and G is…
  274. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    No single-valued function to count zeros of. F is multivalued: going round a zero of ζ or L(χ u ) multiplies |F| by e −π/2 , round a zero of L(χ v ) or L(χ w ) by e +π/2 ; and the full Model A…
  275. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    Littlewood's lemma does transfer — with weights equal to the real parts of the exponents [project] elementary, numerically checked . Continue log F horizontally from the right (the usual…
  276. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    (The residue for imaginary exponents shrinks with the grid step — 0.0099 at t-step 0.04, 0.0020 at 0.005 — as expected from the jumps of arg ζ along the left edge where the horizontal paths pass a…
  277. How much of the critical line can we prove? › 10. Does any of this transfer to the project's hypercomplex objects? [project]
    10.3 Plain summary. Sign changes (Hardy, Selberg) and Levinson's identity need a real-valued function on the line coming from a functional equation. The classical L(ρ) has one; the aligned…
  278. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture [project]
    [known] How to read the labels. Every claim carries one tag. [known] is published mathematics, with the source named (full list in the sources and in the primer ). [project] is a figure or check…
  279. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Example: the Kronecker foliation of the torus [project]
    [known] The Kronecker (linear) foliation of the torus. Opposite sides of the square are glued, as the matching ticks show. If the slope α is irrational, a single leaf is dense; if α is rational,…
  280. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Example: the Reeb foliation of the solid torus [project]
    [known] Left: a meridional disk. The heavy outer circle is the trace of the compact boundary leaf; the interior curves are traces of plane leaves, accumulating on the boundary. Right: a schematic…
  281. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Singular points, and zeros of a vector field [project]
    [known] Four linear types of isolated zero in the plane. The saddle has index −1; the node, the focus and the centre have index +1. Poincaré–Hopf: on a compact oriented manifold, the sum of the…
  282. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Deninger’s proposed dictionary [project]
    [known] as a proposal: Deninger, “Some analogies between number theory and dynamical systems on foliated spaces,” Documenta Mathematica, Extra Volume ICM I (1998), 163–186; and “Analogies between…
  283. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Three toy checks you can follow by hand [project]
    [project] Each of the three examples below was checked by us on 13 November 2026, using PARI/GP and interval arithmetic (Arb). In every case the thing being checked is a [known] identity from the…
  284. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [project]
    [project] As a check of the algebra, we evaluated the Gamma-function expression and 1 − q −s at 384 bits of precision with Arb, on 58 pairs (q, s) with q ∈ {2, 3, 5, 10} and s both real and…
  285. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [project]
    [known] The curve 1 − 2 −s , the regularized determinant of s − θ for q = 2. [project] The sample points mark where the Arb enclosure of the difference contained zero.
  286. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [project]
    [project] The figure below plots s / (1 − q −s ) for q = 2, 3, 10 and shows it approaching 1 / log q as s shrinks. The samples differ from 1 / log q by about s / 2, as the expansion predicts, so…
  287. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › The circle toy: a determinant that equals 1 − q −s [project]
    [known] s · ζ R (s) → 1 / log q as s → 0. [project] Values at s = ±10 −k are plotted, and the gap to 1 / log q is about s / 2.
  288. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Counting zeros of a vector field: three Poincaré–Hopf examples [project]
    [project] We checked three examples, using the sign of the Jacobian determinant and an independent count of how many times the field turns around a small circle:
  289. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Counting zeros of a vector field: three Poincaré–Hopf examples [project]
    [known] Poincaré–Hopf: the sum of the indices of the zeros equals the Euler characteristic of the surface. [project] The three fields drawn here were checked numerically and their indices…
  290. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Closed orbits and closed points: bookkeeping for an elliptic curve over a finite field [project]
    [project] We tested this bookkeeping on ten curve and field pairs (for example y 2 = x 3 + 1 over F 5 , y 2 = x 3 − x over F 17 , and the curve 11a1 over F 7 and F 13 ). In each, the point counts…
  291. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Closed orbits and closed points: bookkeeping for an elliptic curve over a finite field [project]
    [known] Closed points of E over F q correspond to Frobenius orbits, with length |o| · log q. [project] The counts P n for y 2 = x 3 + 1 over F 5 were computed and checked against the Euler product.
  292. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › A first look at the Camacho–Sad index [project]
    [project] The primer above mentions the Camacho–Sad index without computing one. This section computes it on the simplest possible example, so you can see what the number measures. The work was…
  293. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Three results [project]
    [known] Index of an axis. For X = λ 1 x ∂ x + λ 2 y ∂ y , the index of {y = 0} at the origin is CS = λ 2 /λ 1 , and the index of {x = 0} is λ 1 /λ 2 (Camacho–Sad 1982). [project] We confirmed both…
  294. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Three results [project]
    [known] Blowing up the origin. A blow-up replaces the origin by a whole line E (the set of directions through it) and keeps everything else. E has self-intersection E·E = −1. The foliation now has…
  295. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Three results [project]
    [project] Numerical support. With mpmath interval boxes for (λ 1 , λ 2 ), including boxes of width 10 −4 , the interval for the sum of the two indices on E always contains −1. For complex values…
  296. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Three results [project]
    [known] Camacho–Sad indices before and after one blow-up of the origin. [project] The two indices on E sum to −1 = E·E for every choice of λ 1 ≠ λ 2 we tried, symbolic and numerical.
  297. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Reduced versus resonant: a correction [project]
    [project] Ratio −1/n is already reduced. Take λ 1 = n and λ 2 = −1. This is resonant, but a negative ratio is reduced, so no blow-up is needed. We computed the indices for n = 1, …, 4: CS({y = 0})…
  298. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Reduced versus resonant: a correction [project]
    [project] A genuinely non-reduced toy: ratio n, with n a positive integer. Take X = x ∂ x + (n y + x n ) ∂ y . For n ≥ 2 this field is in Poincaré–Dulac normal form and is not linearizable, so no…
  299. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › A trace formula on the circle [project]
    [project] Deninger’s picture asks for a “trace formula” that adds up over closed orbits of a flow and equals a sum over eigenvalues. On the circle toy this formula is not a conjecture: it is…
  300. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › Gaussian check [project]
    [project] We took q = 5, so log q ≈ 1.6094, and h(x) = exp(−x²/(2σ²)), for which ĥ(r) = σ√(2π) · exp(−σ²r²/2) in closed form. We summed both sides to 40 digits with mpmath (the series converge…
  301. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › A compactly supported check [project]
    [project] For a test function with compact support the orbit side is short. Take h(x) = (1 − x²)² for |x| < 1 and 0 otherwise. Since log 5 ≈ 1.609 is larger than 1, every term with k ≠ 0 vanishes,…
  302. Foliations, singular points, and Deninger’s picture › A compactly supported check [project]
    [known] The same number computed two ways, for the Gaussian h(x) = exp(−x²/2) and q = 5. [project] Left: values of h at the orbit lengths k log 5 (orange), times log 5. Right: values of ĥ at the…
  303. What bigger spaces can tell the number line [project]
    [project] This is a map of implications, not progress on RH. [known] means established mathematics; [project] means checked or organized here, not a novelty claim; [speculative] means a missing…
  304. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A return ticket, not just another dimension [project]
    [project] The useful question is not “have we run out of bigger spaces?” It is “what exact bridge carries this particular fact back?” Number-field degree, geometric dimension, representation size…
  305. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A return ticket, not just another dimension [project]
    [project] The solid arrows are logical mechanisms. Dotted arrows need an additional identity or theorem; resemblance alone is not a transfer.
  306. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The larger field really contains ordinary zeta [project]
    [project] We rebuilt 2.42025.8t5.a.a with PARI, matched 5000 arithmetic coefficients exactly, and listed the factors' positive zeros below height 30. Three ordinary zeros, 11 + 21 + 28 quadratic…
  307. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The larger field really contains ordinary zeta [project]
    [project] The green Artin contribution is doubled. The field union is exactly what the factor theorem predicts; the original lists and sampled winding were numerical. New interval contours certify…
  308. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The larger field really contains ordinary zeta [project]
    [project] Two sampled contours agree at winding 348 = 2×173+2, including both signs of the height and the double centre. PARI internally factors its Dedekind evaluator: this is not an independent…
  309. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The larger field really contains ordinary zeta [project]
    [project] A stronger second check: 160-bit interval contours certify total counts 6, 22, 42 and 56 for ordinary ζ and the three quadratics in the rectangle −½≤Re(s)≤1½, |Im(s)|≤30. Together with…
  310. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Where RH really is a theorem [project]
    [project] Take y²=x³+x+1 over the field with five elements. It has 9 points including infinity. Its zeta numerator is 1+3T+5T², with zeros −0.3±0.331662479i. Both have radius exactly 1/√5.
  311. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Where RH really is a theorem [project]
    [project] We checked extension-field point counts exactly through degree 8. The surface E×E shows why higher-dimensional RH has separate cohomological weights, not one universal circle.
  312. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › E₈: the mirror centre has no zeros at all [project]
    [project] Under RH the inherited nonreal zero lines are ½ and 3½. The centre line 2 is zero-free by an exact identity, not merely by this numerical plot.
  313. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A statistical match is not a zero-by-zero implication [project]
    [project] Two completed low-height samples at 25 decimal digits: 1725 pairs from 500 zeros, 17492 pairs from 5000. The larger sample ends at height 5447.861998. Bin RMS discrepancy from GUE…
  314. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A bigger family that already ruled out a whole line [project]
    [project] Twenty 192-bit interval examples illustrate the inequality, but the proof is the universal identity and limit, not those samples.
  315. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Two return tickets turn out to share a matrix [project]
    [project] Using 2048-bit interval arithmetic, we enclosed 50 positive Li coefficients and certified a positive 32×32 compression. Its last elimination pivot is only 1.408×10 −110 . Ordinary…
  316. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A finite approximation that really constrains every zero [project]
    [project] We computed exact-form Gram integrals with 192-bit Arb enclosures and chose explicit rational-decimal coefficients. With generators through a=2 the squared error is 1−log 2≈.306853;…
  317. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A finite approximation that really constrains every zero [project]
    [project] The infinite Gram sums are interval enclosed using a periodic digamma formula, not a finite-tail guess. The experiment supplies a finite bound, not density of the full span or progress…
  318. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A finite approximation that really constrains every zero [project]
    [project] Interval results and exact chosen coefficients · reproduction script .
  319. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › What comes back from our six hypercomplex threads? [project]
    [project] Our octonion star-product toys have no established ordinary-ζ factor. No transfer yet.
  320. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › What comes back from our six hypercomplex threads? [project]
    [project] The present topological information does not constrain the zeros' real parts.
  321. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › And then, back to the actual number line [project]
    [project] A certified zero list through height 30 is not that all-height premise. A finite-range prime estimate would also need a controlled explicit-formula tail. The return ticket is real; the…
  322. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Which return tickets actually carry weight? [project]
    [project] First: a factor that cannot be cancelled. Second: an exact criterion with all its quantifiers intact. Third: a certified extraction map from larger fields. Geometric analogies and family…
  323. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Which factor owns the zero? [project]
    [project] The honest ceiling: a hypothetical off-line ordinary zero of multiplicity m can occur in every field with the same order M=m, while all extra factors stay nonzero. Restriction identities…
  324. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A different computation really comes back down [project]
    [project] We then stopped evaluating ordinary ζ and character L-factors. Each proper subfield zeta was computed from its own prime-ideal splitting data, certified units and a Gaussian smoothed…
  325. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A different computation really comes back down [project]
    [project] “Independent” means a different computation, not different mathematical information. The coefficients still encode the same functions. This verifies a long-known finite result, not RH.…
  326. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The notebook behind the tangent [project]
    [project] Version downward-20261110-v1 . The research keeps exact arithmetic, non-interval numerical checks, established theorems and speculative programs separate. No joint-field claim and no…
  327. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › The notebook behind the tangent [project]
    [project] Continue with the hypercomplex exploration , zero statistics , or the ordinary RH page .
  328. Zeros and primes › Octonion counts: which count hears the zeros? [project, exact from established factors]
    [project, exact from established factors] First choose what is being counted. Our octonion orders have global ideal zetas Z K (s)=ζ(8s)C K (2 −s ). It is tempting to rebuild the ordinary ideal…
  329. Zeros and primes › Octonion counts: which count hears the zeros? [project, computed]
    [project, computed] A: exact count errors in a fixed strip, four kinds. B: the common zero-sensitive part, normalized by 8x 1/16 ; grey joins exact arithmetic samples, colours use 5,20,100…
  330. Zeros and primes › The zero waves belong to B, not A [project, computed]
    [project, computed] The exact counts agree through bound 2 128 by finite-correction and odd-part algorithms, plus a separate 394,809-event enumeration at that bound. Every integer prefix through 2…
  331. Zeros on the critical line › The critical strip and the line [project]
    [project] Example on the first cut: |ζ(0.2 + it)| = 0.2694 and |ζ(0.8 + it)| = 0.2113. Their ratio is 1.2753, and |χ(0.2 + it)| = 1.2753. Different sizes, but locked together.
  332. Zeros on the critical line › Gram’s law at three heights [project]
    [project] Beyond the plane: the critical line in quaternions and octonions —an illustrated, numerically checked exploration of zero spheres and what they do not prove.

Known + project (47)

Known mathematics, with our own check, illustration or computation added.

  1. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where ½ and the zeros go [known / project, illustration]
    [known / project, illustration] The pair ½ ± iγ becomes ½ + γS² in the intrinsic quaternion lift. First sample the i–j great circle, then other latitudes. These are directions on one fixed zero…
  2. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 · Quaternion arithmetic: when the mirror forces a zero [known/project]
    [known/project] Q₈’s relevant matrices preserve a skew form, and their Frobenius–Schur indicator is −1; we checked those representation facts directly. Artin Euler factors use matrix determinants,…
  3. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now checked: explicit fields, different answers [known / project checked]
    [known / project checked] We also reproduced the Magma handbook’s classic Armitage example , the third row. Its degree-eight polynomial reduces exactly to LMFDB’s polynomial, its field…
  4. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Now checked: explicit fields, different answers [known / project checked]
    [known / project checked] The linked primary database records give both signs. We independently checked each exact field, its full quaternion group and its two-dimensional character. Then we…
  5. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Not every “quaternion zeta” vanishes at ½ [known / project checked]
    [known / project checked] A factor tending to zero cancels zeta’s pole; taking the analytic limit leaves a finite nonzero number. We checked that limit from both sides. This is a useful warning:…
  6. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, float numerics + proof from known local facts]
    [project, float numerics + proof from known local facts] A forced zero at the centre. In the 120-element field above, both 2-dimensional L-functions have root number +1, so nothing forces them to…
  7. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Complex s: where the complex i lives matters [project, proved from known local facts]
    [known] The root number is a product of local signs, one for each prime and one for the real place, and for a character χ the local constants satisfy ε(χ)ε(χ⁻¹) = χ(−1) (Tate, Corvallis 1979).…
  8. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Beyond the first zeros: complete through height 50 [known / project]
    [known / project] The comparison is M N (T) = (T/π) log(√N T/(2πe)), the leading smooth term for a degree-two Artin function. It is not an exact integer prediction . The full symmetric counts,…
  9. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Quaternion orders: counting ideals changes the zeros [known / project]
    [known / project] D records the finite ramified primes—the primes where the algebra does not split into ordinary two-by-two matrices. We checked actual maximal orders, not just formal expressions:…
  10. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Quaternion orders: counting ideals changes the zeros [known / project]
    [known / project] A nontrivial zeta zero ρ supplies zeros at ρ/2 and (ρ + 1)/2. For the familiar zeros ρ = ½ + iγ, these sit at ¼ + iγ/2 and ¾ + iγ/2 . The local factor also supplies exact zeros…
  11. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Quaternion orders: counting ideals changes the zeros [known formula / project numerical checks]
    [known formula / project numerical checks] Green points are selected inherited zeros; gold points are the exact local-factor family. The empty crossed centre matters: a factor vanishes there, but…
  12. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The missing zero at the middle [known / project]
    [known / project] Its completed functional equation still reflects s ↔ 1 − s. Thus a mirror centre is not necessarily a line containing all zeros. Also keep the exponent convention: this function…
  13. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The missing zero at the middle [known consequence / project checked]
    [known consequence / project checked] One useful counter-control: D = 30 has three finite ramified primes. Three local-factor zeros cancel just one pole, so this order zeta has a double central…
  14. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The whole real axis: a ladder of half-steps [known formula · project 60-digit check]
    [known formula · project 60-digit check] A sign-change scan from −8.2 to 0.98 at 60 digits found exactly these 16 roots per row, each with nonzero slope, and reproduced the centre and pole…
  15. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The whole real axis: a ladder of half-steps [known / project · sources and reproduction]
    [known / project · sources and reproduction] Voight’s original chapter · Exact order arithmetic and numerical checks · Bases, products, values and residuals · Definitions and full derivation .
  16. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [known / project, illustration]
    [known / project, illustration] Three already known zeros, rescaled as ρ/λ. Hollow circles mark their original positions. Changing λ changes the function: nothing moves inside one fixed zeta. At…
  17. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [known / project, proved]
    [known / project, proved] [project, computer-assisted] The same axes compare the four global counts. Green: 102 certified inherited zeros divided by eight. Rust: local numerator zeros, with…
  18. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Putting the primes together: the four global zetas [known / project, proved]
    [known / project, proved] The full zero description is: every ordinary nontrivial zero ρ divided by eight; the trivial zeros s = −k/4 for k = 1, 2, …; and the correction zeros just described. An…
  19. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A mirror pairs zeros. It does not pin them. [known / project]
    [known / project] Bushnell–Reiner’s 1980 Theorem 2 and remarks, pp. 156–158, were re-read for this comparison. Their Fourier/contragredient argument uses associative orders and a simple…
  20. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Why are octonion orders strange at 2? [known / project, proved]
    [project, computer-assisted] All four reductions have 256 elements, but they are not the same algebra. G/2G becomes commutative and associative ; O/2O remains a noncommutative, nonassociative…
  21. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Part II · Where the extra directions make a difference [known/project]
    [known/project] A j-plane is not a separate universe with different axioms: the plane spanned by 1 and j is an ordinary copy of the complex plane. The difference appears when we mix directions or…
  22. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A sphere really can turn into one point [known/project]
    [known/project] Multiplying by the coefficient-conjugate partner using the slice product restores real coefficients and a full zero sphere. This normal function is not generally the pointwise…
  23. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Turn from i toward j and k [known/project]
    [known/project] “One point per sphere” also needs a qualification: if the character and its conjugate vanish at matching opposite points, the whole sphere can vanish. Our four examples have…
  24. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › When a familiar formula changes—or stops being a single answer [known/project]
    [known/project] This does not break zeta’s own Euler product: at one fixed q, all of its real-coefficient factors lie in the same commuting complex slice. It tells us exactly which assumption…
  25. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › When a familiar formula changes—or stops being a single answer [known/project]
    [known/project] Gamma, sine and positive-base power factors in zeta’s functional equation still commute at one intrinsic input, so that equation extends correctly. At apparent 0 × ∞ expressions,…
  26. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › What happens to the rest of the toolkit? [known/project]
    [known/project] A real function of the imaginary radius. Direction adds nothing. Compare full zero counts with critical counts with multiplicity ; sign changes alone can miss zeros.
  27. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › What happens to the rest of the toolkit? [known/project]
    [known/project] The same Möbius numbers and the same real M(x). In Re q > 1, the inverse Dirichlet series and Mertens integral work inside each slice. The RH growth criterion is unchanged.
  28. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › What happens to the rest of the toolkit? [known/project]
    [known/project] The same entire real-coefficient function. Its RH criterion concerns the positive real ray . It cannot be promoted to a polynomial bound in every direction: R(−x) behaves like −xeˣ.
  29. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The horned-sphere question was not finished [known/project]
    [known/project] Small regular surfaces |ξ| = c around a simple zero sphere are actual tubes, S² × S¹ in quaternion space and S⁶ × S¹ in octonion space. Their finite local geometry is tame. Their…
  30. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A precise answer about the loops at infinity [known/project]
    [known/project] This is a useful distinction from Alexander’s horned sphere, not proof that we have found one. Our compactified zero set is not even locally connected at infinity. Alexander’s…
  31. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › Where octonions actually behave differently [known/project]
    [known/project] For an octonionic construction using three independent directions, even parentheses become data: (e₁e₂)e₄ = e₇, while e₁(e₂e₄) = −e₇ in our checked convention. Alternativity…
  32. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › A three-direction toy: the parentheses move the zero [known/project · important correction]
    [known/project · important correction] For a finite pointwise octonion product, parentheses cannot change the zero set. Norms multiply, so a product is zero exactly when one factor is zero, under…
  33. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › E₈: a real lattice difference, and a different mirror centre [known/project · exact enumeration]
    [known/project · exact enumeration] Another route starts with a lattice: a repeating collection of points in eight real coordinates. E₈ is connected with integral octonions, but counting its…
  34. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › E₈: a real lattice difference, and a different mirror centre [project · numerical check of known identities]
    [project · numerical check of known identities] At 80 decimal digits, reflected complex values agree to better than 10 −70 ; an independent theta-integral continuation agrees with the factor…
  35. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › E₈: a real lattice difference, and a different mirror centre [known/project · normalization matters]
    [known/project · normalization matters] Sum |v| −8u instead and we have simply written s = 4u. The mirror becomes u ↔ 1 − u, with midpoint ½. That change of variable does not put every zero on ½.…
  36. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › E₈: a real lattice difference, and a different mirror centre [known/project · sources and reproduction]
    [known/project · sources and reproduction] Viazovska’s E₈ definition and E₄ expansion · Nebe’s classical theta-series exposition · Enumeration and checks · Recorded values · Full derivation and…
  37. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny ways things differ: a map [known / project]
    [known / project] “Quaternion zeta” can mean different constructions. Extra directions, different arithmetic and different multiplication rules do not make the same change. Here are six precise…
  38. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny ways things differ: a map [known / project]
    [known / project] Six different mechanisms, not six claims about ordinary zeta. Follow the linked sections for assumptions and proof status.
  39. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny ways things differ: a map [known / project]
    [known / project] Zero directions
  40. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny ways things differ: a map [known / project]
    [known / project] Forced central zero
  41. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny ways things differ: a map [known / project]
    [known / project] Bracket-moved roots
  42. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny ways things differ: a map [known / project]
    [known / project] Extra zero families
  43. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › The tiny ways things differ: a map [known / project]
    [known / project] A different mirror centre
  44. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › Turn Frobenius; keep its proven radius [known / project illustration]
    [known / project illustration] After dividing each Frobenius eigenvalue by √5, both lie on the unit circle. Extending the field to 5ⁿ raises them to the nth power: their angles multiply while the…
  45. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › What comes back from our six hypercomplex threads? [known / project]
    [known / project] Not from direction alone. A separate character-product factorization may provide one.
  46. What bigger spaces can tell the number line › A different computation really comes back down [known / project]
    [known / project] The factor ½ is essential: twice the ordinary order equals the three quadratic-subfield orders minus the biquadratic order. The same identity recovers ordinary orders 0,1,1,1 at…
  47. Zeros and primes › Octonion counts: which count hears the zeros? [known / project adaptation]
    [known / project adaptation] Zeros enter a different observable. Taking −Z′/Z makes each zero into a pole. Its coefficients are signed weights, not numbers of ideals or octonion prime ideals.…

Original proof (7)

Proved here by an elementary argument; not found in the sources we checked.

What “original proof” means here, plainly. These statements were argued in this project, on 10 November 2026, and we did not find them in the sources we checked: the sections we read of John Voight, Quaternion Algebras (2021), and of Denert’s and Brzezinski’s work on zeta functions of orders (no explicit invertible count Qrinv there, and no ready-made local functional equation for a non-hereditary Eichler order’s all-modules zeta); and Lakatos’s coefficient test for self-inversive polynomials, which covers only the levels r ≤ p+1. Not finding something is weak evidence. A paper we missed may already contain it, and that paper would have priority. The arguments are elementary (careful counting and sign changes), they have not been peer-reviewed, they are not new deep mathematics, and none is a claim about the Riemann Hypothesis. Q1–Q3 and the other three arguments were re-derived line by line in our own referee pass (PROOF-REFEREE-20261110.md). On the night of 10–11 November a second referee pass (BLOCK2-REFEREE-20261110.md) checked the all-level Solomon formula and a shorter Chebyshev circle proof, and re-derived Q4 by a third method, so the Solomon sign lemma no longer depends on a guessed closed form. These referee passes were done within this project, not by outside reviewers. Earlier project proofs on the site (for example the exact deductions on the quaternion page) were not added in this pass: they have not yet been checked against the literature to this standard, and interval certificates are computations rather than proofs argued by hand.

  1. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 1 · How many invertible ideals there are [original proof]
    [project · proved] [original proof] For every prime p and level r, the number a e of invertible right ideals of reduced norm p e is (e+1)p e when e < r, and [((r+1)p − (r−1))p e − (p+1)p r−1…
  2. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 2 · Every one of those zeros is on the half-line [original proof]
    [project · proved] [original proof] Every root of Q r inv has |u| = 1/p. Since |u| = p −2·Re s , that is exactly Re s = ½: all of these local zeros sit on the half-line. The idea of the proof is a…
  3. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Counting all modules, not just invertible ones [original proof]
    [original proof] Q 1 = 2 for every r ≥ 1 (the algebra modulo p has exactly two simple modules, so exactly two maximal right ideals).
  4. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Counting all modules, not just invertible ones [original proof]
    [original proof] Q 2 = p+2 for every r ≥ 2 (there are exactly 2p+3 modules of index p 2 ).
  5. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Counting all modules, not just invertible ones [original proof]
    [original proof] Q 3 = 2(p+1) for every r ≥ 3 (exactly 4(p+1) modules of index p 3 ; re-derived in the referee pass).
  6. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 3 · Counting all modules, not just invertible ones [original proof]
    [original proof] Q 4 = p 2 +2p+2 for every r ≥ 4 (exactly 3p 2 +6p+5 modules of index p 4 ). Re-checked in the night referee pass by a third, different method (a full four-dimensional Hermite-form…
  7. The critical line in quaternions and octonions › 4 · Those zeros are on the half-line too [original proof]
    [project · proved, refereed] [original proof] Every root of the Solomon factor has |v| = p −1/2 , which again means Re s = ½. The proof is the same sign-counting idea with a more elaborate curve:…