Zeta Zeros
Display
Theme
Motion

Primer · before the zeros

Complex numbers: the plane behind the zeros

The zeros of ζ live in the complex plane. This page builds that plane from scratch: what i is, why anyone wanted it, how to picture it, and why the line with real part 1/2 matters. Every figure is computed, not drawn by hand.

1. A definition, not a discovery

No ordinary number squares to −1: a positive times itself is positive, and so is a negative. So mathematicians simply defined a new number, written i, by the rule

i² = −1.

Everything else follows by the usual rules of arithmetic. A complex number is anything of the form a + bi, where a and b are ordinary (real) numbers: a is its real part and b its imaginary part. The word “imaginary” is an accident of history; i is no less legitimate than −1 or √2.

2. Why anyone wanted it: cubics, not quadratics

For a quadratic like x² + 1 = 0, people were happy to say “no solution.” The pressure came from cubic equations. Gerolamo Cardano published a formula for them in Ars Magna (1545). Rafael Bombelli, in his Algebra (1572), noticed that for x³ = 15x + 4 the formula asks for √−121, even though the equation has three perfectly real answers, one of them 4. He pushed through anyway, treating √−1 by fixed rules, and the imaginary parts cancelled to give the real answer.

Figure 1 Why i was invented: Bombelli’s cubic Settled

Graph of the cubic y = x³ − 15x − 4 crossing zero at -3.732, -0.268 and 4. Beside it, Cardano’s formula with √−121 and Bombelli’s check that (2 + i)³ = 2 + 11i, so the cube roots 2 + i and 2 − i add up to 4.
Computed: the roots of x³ − 15x − 4 are 4 and −2 ± √3 (-3.7321, -0.2679); (2 + i)³ = 2 + 11i. Inside Cardano’s square root sits (q/2)² − (p/3)³ = 4 − 125 = -121. Settled history: Cardano 1545, Bombelli 1572. Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for reduced motion.

3. The picture: a second number line, at right angles

Where does i go on the number line? Nowhere: it gets its own line. Draw the real numbers left to right as usual, and the multiples of i (i, 2i, −i …) bottom to top. The two lines cross at 0 and together make a flat grid, the complex plane. The number 2 + 3i is the point 2 steps across and 3 steps up.

Settled A common misreading: i does not bend or curve the number line. The real line stays straight and the plane is flat. What i does is turn, as the next section shows. Caspar Wessel (1799), Jean-Robert Argand (1806) and Carl Friedrich Gauss (1831) made this picture standard; Gauss’s 1831 paper is why it is often called the Gaussian plane.

Figure 2 The complex plane: a second line at right angles Settled

A flat square grid. The horizontal real number line runs from −5 to 5; an identical line labelled in multiples of i swings up by a quarter turn to become the vertical axis. The point 2 + 3i is reached by 2 steps across and 3 steps up.
The vertical axis starts on top of the real line and rotates by 90° into place: the same straight line, turned. Settled Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for reduced motion.

4. Multiplying is turning and stretching

Every point of the plane has a length (its distance from 0) and an angle (measured anticlockwise from the positive real direction). The key fact, the reason complex numbers are useful, is:

to multiply two complex numbers, multiply their lengths and add their angles.

The number i has length 1 and angle 90°, so multiplying by i is a pure quarter turn: 1 → i → −1 → −i → 1. Two quarter turns make a half turn, which sends 1 to −1. That is all i² = −1 says.

Figure 3 Multiplying turns and stretches Settled

Arrows for 2 + i and 1 + 2i, each of length √5, at angles 26.57° and 63.43°. A gold spiral carries 2 + i to the product 5i, of length 5 and angle 90°. A small wheel shows a pointer stepping 1, i, −1, −i.
Computed: |2 + i| = |1 + 2i| = 2.2361 and |5i| = 5; the angles 26.5651° + 63.4349° = 90°. The spiral is the path z·|w|seis·arg w for s from 0 to 1. Settled Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for reduced motion.

5. Euler’s formula: motion on a circle

Leonhard Euler, in his Introductio in analysin infinitorum (1748), found that the exponential function and the circle are the same thing seen two ways:

eit = cos t + i sin t.

Read it as motion: as t increases, the point eit walks around the circle of radius 1 at steady speed, having travelled a distance t along it. At t = π it has gone halfway round and sits at −1. That gives Euler’s identity, eiπ = −1 (often written eiπ + 1 = 0). Its honest meaning is not mystical: half a turn around the unit circle lands on −1. It is beautiful because it ties together the exponential, the circle (π) and turning (i).

Figure 4 Euler’s formula on the unit circle Settled

The unit circle with 1, i, −1 and −i marked, and a red pointer turning around it. Beside it, the real part cos t and imaginary part sin t for t from 0 to 2π; at t = π they are −1 and 0.
Computed with Python cmath: eiπ evaluates to -1 + 1.2e-16i, the tiny imaginary part being rounding in floating point. Settled Euler 1748. Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for reduced motion.

6. A function moves the whole plane

An ordinary function takes a number on a line to a number on a line. A complex function takes a point of the plane to a point of the plane, so the way to picture one is to draw a grid and see where every line goes. Squaring, z ↦ z², doubles each angle and squares each length: the grid bends into parabolas, still crossing at right angles. The exponential, z ↦ ez, wraps a strip around the origin, turning vertical lines into circles and horizontal lines into rays. The plane stays flat; it is the grid lines that the function bends.

Colouring each point by the angle of the output gives a phase portrait. For z² the colours go round the origin twice. The same colouring applied to ζ is the phase map of ζ, where each zero shows up as a point where all the colours meet.

Figure 5 A grid before and after z² and e^z Settled

Three panels. A square grid coloured by angle; the same grid after squaring, bent into parabolas with the colours going round twice; and a grid on a horizontal strip after the exponential map, which becomes circles and rays around the origin.
Computed with Python cmath: 13 + 13 grid lines on [−1.5, 1.5]² (left, middle) and on [−1, 1] × [−π, π] (right), each sampled at 81 points and mapped exactly. Settled Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for reduced motion.

7. The bridge to ζ

Now the zeros. ζ is a function from the plane to the plane, and a zero is an input s where ζ(s) = 0.

  • Settled The imaginary axis is the vertical line where the real part is 0: numbers 0 + ti. The critical line is a different vertical line, half a unit to its right: numbers 1/2 + ti.
  • Settled The critical strip is everything with real part strictly between 0 and 1. All the nontrivial zeros lie in it. The trivial zeros are −2, −4, −6, … on the real axis; they come from the functional equation and are well understood (see the trivial zeros).
  • Settled Feed every point 1/2 + it of the critical line into ζ and plot the outputs: you get a curve that loops around the origin. Each time it passes exactly through 0 is a zero on the line. The first is at t ≈ 14.1347.
  • Open The Riemann Hypothesis says every nontrivial zero has real part exactly 1/2. It is not proved. Every zero checked so far, up to height 3·1012, is on the line, but checking is not proof.

Figure 6 The critical line and the loop of ζ(1/2 + it) Settled

Left: the plane from real part −7 to 2 and height 0 to 50, showing the imaginary axis, the shaded critical strip, the dashed critical line at real part 1/2 with zeros at heights 14.13, 21.02, 25.01, 30.42, 32.94, 37.59, 40.92, 43.33, 48.01, 49.77, and trivial zeros at −2, −4, −6. Right: the curve ζ(1/2 + it) for t from 0 to 50, looping and passing through the origin once at each zero.
Computed with mpmath 1.4.1: zetazero(k) for k = 1 to 10, and ζ(1/2 + it) at 1001 points with step 0.05 for 0 ≤ t ≤ 50 (values beyond ±4.2 clipped to the frame). ζ(1/2) ≈ −1.4604. The heights of the zeros on the left are the moments the right-hand curve hits 0. Settled as computation; the claim that all zeros behave this way is Open. Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for reduced motion.

8. A fun true fact: knight moves are Gaussian integers

Complex numbers a + bi with whole-number a and b are called Gaussian integers (Gauss studied them in 1831). Their norm is a² + b², the squared length. Put a knight on the square 0 of a board drawn on the plane: its eight jumps land exactly on the Gaussian integers of norm 5, namely ±1 ± 2i and ±2 ± i. That is true, but it is a curiosity, not a deep link between chess and ζ.

  • Settled 5 = (1 + 2i)(1 − 2i). An odd prime splits into two Gaussian factors exactly when it leaves remainder 1 on division by 4 (Fermat’s two-squares theorem). Primes like 3 and 7, with remainder 3, do not split, so no leaper move has squared length 3 or 7. The race between these two kinds of prime is on the prime races page of the Prime Distribution site.
  • Settled The number of Gaussian integers of norm n is 4 × (divisors of n that are 1 mod 4 − divisors that are 3 mod 4). The zeta function that counts them, the Dedekind zeta function of the Gaussian integers, factors as ζ(s) · L(s, χ4), where L(s, χ4) is the L-function of the remainder-mod-4 pattern. Its first zero is at 1/2 + 6.0209i (see zeros of other L-functions).
  • Open Whether all nontrivial zeros of L(s, χ4) lie on the critical line is part of the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis. Results that depend on it are conditional.

Figure 7 Knight moves as Gaussian integers Settled

A 7 by 7 board with a knight on the centre square, taken as 0. Lines run to the eight reachable squares, labelled 1 + 2i, 2 + i, 2 − i, 1 − 2i, −1 − 2i, −2 − i, −2 + i and −1 + 2i. Beside it, bars count the Gaussian integers of norm n for n from 1 to 25; n = 5 gives 8.
Computed: a direct count of a + bi with a² + b² = n for n = 1 to 25 agrees with the divisor formula in every case; n = 5 gives 8, n = 25 gives 12, and n = 3, 7, 11, 19, 21, 23 give 0. Settled (Gauss 1831; Jacobi’s two-squares formula). Motion plays on load and is off if your system asks for reduced motion.

Where to go next

With the plane in hand, the next page, zeros on the critical line, follows ζ along the line 1/2 + it in detail.

Reading path · step 2 of 13